Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna"
by BobbyH on Sunday August 08, 2010 @04:06PM
(#1586022)
HN does not use the popularity of previous stories from that domain as a weight. It uses the number of votes, adjusted for the amount of time it's been since the link or comment was added. So if a story has 8 votes after 1 minute, it will rank much higher than a story that has 8 votes after 1 day.
details: http://blog.linkibol.com/2010/05/07/how-to-build-a-popularit...
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna"
by drivebyacct2 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @06:24PM
(#1586345)
I understand this. Which part of this particular Gruber post was new, interesting, analytical, etc? It was repetition of news that surely everywhere here is aware of, along with Gruber's double think to explain that an antenna antenuating when touched is not a fundamental flaw of an antenna.
"seeing what other HN-ers opinions are on Grubers posts does interest me".
This seems exceeding obvious at this point, the comments are nearly identical on any of Gruber's latest posts.
I presume the front-page algorithm has some sort of "magic" in it so that the only articles making it to the front page are that which a significant proportion of the user base would want there. Is that not correct?
Not every post is going to be interesting everyone, but as I mentioned before, the originating URL makes it easy to spot ones from URL's you know that you're not interested in.
Myself, I am a bit of an apple fanboy - and seeing what other HN-ers opinions are on Grubers posts does interest me. I think there are probably a fair few apple fanboys on HN who agree with me.
On a similar, but unrelated note, most (not all) of the articles I read on HN I've already seen through some other means anyway. It's really only the comments that I'm interested in, which are generally of vastly superior quality than that of the originating site (if it has them).
edit: at the time of writing, the story does only have 8 votes. Is HN using popularity of previous stories from that domain to push it to the front page quicker? It does seem a little odd - maybe I'm wrong, and the users of HN really don't care about this story anymore.