Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna"
by mlinsey on Sunday August 08, 2010 @03:08PM
(#1585900)
Reading your comment on my iPhone 4 made me curious: after a few minutes of trying, I can't make the signal drop enough to lose bars by touching it anywhere besides the gap between antennas, which makes me lose two bars every time. Even if touching it anywhere should theoretically cause a problem, it's definitely much more pronounced when you bridge the gap.
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna"
by tptacek on Sunday August 08, 2010 @05:21PM
(#1586195)
Agreeing and adding the data point that having band-aided the "death gap" on my antenna, I get significantly better reception on my i4 than I did on my 3G. I think the original commenter's point is a crock.
Re:John Gruber about Papermaster and "That Damn Antenna"
by ergo98 on Sunday August 08, 2010 @06:44PM
(#1586387)
Just to confirm: You believe that touching an external antenna doesn't detune or attenuate the signal. That's a fascinating belief that goes completely against all antenna design.
It's interesting that the iPhone 4 is the first device with a touchable antenna, and that was done purely to reduce the size of the device. Must be magic.
I fully expect an upcoming revision of the iPhone -- perhaps even the white version and then a Rev.B black version, to have a coating on the antenna.A simply layer of epoxy and it would still look groovy and would eliminate almost all of the issues. The downside is how that will wear over time, which I'm sure they're testing right now.