Given a scenario, ask the following:
"If enforced, will this give the users a financial incentive to pick one information source on the Net over another to get the same content?"
If the answer is YES, then the scenario is a violation of net neutrality principles.
So for the 4 scenarios you listed, the answers would be YES, YES, LIKELY NOT, and NO*
(*only because we restrict the test to sources on the Net).
https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2015/11/comca...
Would you really require cable ISPs provide you an internet bandwidth of X and video bandwidth of Y instead of internet bandwidth of X+Y?
Consider an alternate history, where TV was invented after the internet. ISPs propose to offer TV service (exempt from data caps of course) at the expense of last mile bandwidth, which is otherwise subject to caps. I think that would be recognized as a net neutrality violation.
It feels unreasonable because we know the cost of providing television service scales with the number of subscribers, not the usage per subscriber. Of course, that's also true for internet service outside peak hours - a fixed monthly cap does not match the unit costs of providing internet at all.
I think pragmatic regulation would exempt existing cases like this. We wouldn't permit a new case like it in the future, though.
In theory, the problem you refer to should be addressed by anti-monopoly laws (NN is a tool to address a different problem).
1. Zero rating. Wikipedia+facebook is free, everything else counts towards the cap. This was a subject of major debate in India.
2. First party zero rating - YouTube and Vonage count towards the cap, your ISP's streaming video or VOIP service does not.
3. Negotiated zero rating. "binge on" and similar, which is basically vendor neutral but limits the type of content excluded from the cap.
4. Extremely small caps. If YouTube counts toward the cap and TV doesn't, you won't cancel your cable package. This gives cable+ISPs a big incentive to keep caps low.
I view #1 and #2 to be clear violations of NN, and #3 as borderline. #4 is just a consequence of ISP monopoly - but it's not NN.