Neither do collectible stamps, yet people buy them regularly. The most expensive one costing $200K, with the face value of 15 cents.
"On May 22, 2010, the yellow stamp was auctioned once again by David Feldman in Geneva, Switzerland. It sold "for at least the $2.3 million price [that] it set a record for in 1996"." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treskilling_Yellow
Um, yes.. as long as Apple shares can be sold for USD (which they can).
And it sounds like these “cryptogkitties” can be sold for ETH. Your analogy confuses me.
The same cannot be said of these kittens... that this obvious point even needs to be stated is just sad.
To suggest that these things are anything other that highly speculative is intellectually dishonest at best, gambling at worst.
Google shares don't pay any dividends at all.
Why exactly do people pay 1,000 USD for one share of GOOGL?
Are they buying an option on the right to receive dividends at some indeterminate point in the distant future?
Do they think they'll receive a fraction of the enterprise value when Google gets bought by a bigger company?
Will Google get sold off piece by piece and they'll get a pro-rata share of the liquidation proceeds?
Why would you pay "real money" for an electronic entry in the broker's ledger for an intangible asset that may never get converted back into USD?
> Do they think they'll receive a fraction of the enterprise value when Google gets bought by a bigger company?
> Will Google get sold off piece by piece and they'll get a pro-rata share of the liquidation proceeds?
Yes, but also a bet on other people's demand for those things - its asset backed. Since they all are based on USD I think they're a little safer bet than a cat fad.
Exactly.
> its asset backed
Not really. Google's assets minus its liabilities are $139 billion. The value of its stock is $724 billion.
So 81% of the company's value isn't "backed" by anything -- not the company's assets, not the promise to pay dividends in the future, nothing.
No, that’s not paying dividends, that’s diluting share value.
The logical thing to do for a recipient of more shares is to sell them into the market for currency, thus diluting the value of remaining shares.
It doesn't pay dividends in ETH, it pays dividends in more kitties. Is that really a dividend?
If apple shares could only pay dividends in more apple shares instead of USD would they have any value?
> This is ethereum we are talking about. If the ether was bought 1 year ago today, it would have cost $1,557.1. Someone could have made a $1.5k investment 1 year ago which is now paying for itself weekly.
Ethereum at least has a purpose, cryptokitties do not seem to have one. Besides, you can't just say that the price of one crypto asset will go up because a different one has gone up in the past!