News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Dream setup for a “smart” home? by brudgers on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @11:06AM (#15852566)
I'd run Cat 5 and use Raspberry Pi's and relays and such. Generic materials and material methods are the way to go with any construction project. Maybe some solar panels and lead acid batteries. It's a systems integration problem. A dependency on the app store has low reliability over a five year period. Wireless systems will be increasingly vulnerable because they are consumer devices and therefore have short term firmware support (and the FCC prohibits sale of wireless devices with user modifiable software in the US).

I'd put it another way, a functional smart home is primarily a design, engineering, and construction project not a shopping exercise.

Re:Ask HN: Dream setup for a “smart” home? by CyberFonic on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @09:33PM (#15858040)
I totally agree with you. With the current state of the market, a fully integrated smart home is only attainable to those who have the requisite engineering know how and skills or are willing to pay for professional design, installation and support.

Conceptually smart homes have a lot of potential benefits but as the market currently stands, I don't see how it will become mainstream any time soon. Rather like PCs were in the 1980s.