News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Books I read this year by coldtea on Monday December 04, 2017 @03:21PM (#15847082)
>That's not presenting an explanation of how it would not be racism, that's presenting an explanation of the manner in which the racism was formed.

The explanation about it not being racist is simple: this has nothing to do with your race, and more with what your people and army did to them.

Others with the same race as you, but different nationality, wouldn't haven't gotten the same treatment, thus, not racist.

Re:Books I read this year by stinkytaco on Monday December 04, 2017 @04:47PM (#15847842)
Given the arbitrary nature of "race", this strikes me as splitting hairs. We group so many races under the umbrella of "white" that I think it's fairly safe to include discrimination against "the other" as racism, but that just shows the arbitrariness of race as a classification.
Re:Books I read this year by coldtea on Monday December 04, 2017 @05:35PM (#15848187)
Well, if the other's country has bombed yours, when you've done nothing to them, and you were 10,000 miles away from their borders, then it's quite safe to assume non race-based motivations for hating them too...
Re:Books I read this year by TeMPOraL on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:21AM (#15850353)
I agree, we need a better word for that. When Poles complain about Germans because our grandparents were killed by their grandparents in WWII, you don't call this "racism", because there's no racial or ethnic difference. The situation here is similar - it's resentment because of a military invasion.
Re:Books I read this year by dragonwriter on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @02:46AM (#15850445)
> When Poles complain about Germans because our grandparents were killed by their grandparents in WWII, you don't call this "racism", because there's no racial or ethnic difference.

There is, in fact, an ethnic difference between Germans and Poles. On the other hand, you are correct that people often don't describe something as racism if they feel it is justified (or at least excusable) based on history.

It still is racism, and a lot of what is described as racism has similar roots; people are highly selective (and often racist) on which ethnic bigotries they describe as “racism”.

Re:Books I read this year by coldtea on Tuesday December 05, 2017 @03:56PM (#15855875)
>you are correct that people often don't describe something as racism if they feel it is justified (or at least excusable) based on history.

They also don't describe something as racism if it's not based on race.

>It still is racism, and a lot of what is described as racism has similar roots; people are highly selective (and often racist) on which ethnic bigotries they describe as “racism”.

It seems like you fall into the error of describe something as racism if you feel it is not justified and non-excusable, not caring one iota whether it has to do with race or not.

Most ethnic bigotries are totally unrelated to race. And not forgiving some country for bombing yours, or gasing your parents in concentration camps is not an "ethnic bigotry" anyway.