News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Taking Children Seriously by analog31 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @06:32PM (#15840281)
Here's a puzzle that I've struggled with: I love critical rationalism, but I'm a terrible debater and negotiator. Put in the context of raising kids, if they ask "why" and end up winning the debate despite being wrong, do they get their way?

Should my own actions be dictated by anybody who happens to be a better debater than me? I hope the hell not.

What if the options at hand aren't as crystal clear as the textbook cases that tend to be cited in discussions and books, and the illusion of rationality is just that? What if debate skill is not strictly rational, or even informational, but includes an emotional component plus time pressure?

I suspect that what we consider to be "irrational" approaches, such as asserting our own authority, are in fact survival skills that reflect the limitations of rational debate.

Re:Taking Children Seriously by throwawayjava on Sunday December 03, 2017 @06:41PM (#15840327)
> but includes an emotional component plus time pressure?

You don't even need those things. Intelligence and practice will suffice, even for "purely rational arguments".

Defending Truth makes debates easier to win, but isn't a necessary or sufficient condition.

Re:Taking Children Seriously by analog31 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @07:15PM (#15840488)
Maybe motivation is a factor too. Debate and negotiation are not games that I anticipate enjoying, whereas spending intelligence and practice on becoming a better musician motivates me. ;-)

Also, I suspect that Truth isn't always easy to discern, especially in a world where we're immersed in tradeoffs and complex systems.

Re:Taking Children Seriously by erasemus on Sunday December 03, 2017 @07:27PM (#15840546)
>Debate and negotiation are not games that I anticipate enjoying

Yes and I think that's because they entail criticism, which is used to attack ideas and people we don't like. Whereas creating something worthwhile is about discovering or perceiving something already inside the mind that we do like (and therefore cannot seriously attempt to criticize). Building a family is an attempt to create something worthwhile.

Re:Taking Children Seriously by analog31 on Sunday December 03, 2017 @08:08PM (#15840728)
I'm reminded of a saying: "It takes a carpenter to build a shed, but a jackass can knock it down."