Re:Software Giant Autodesk to Axe 13% of Global Workforce
by sime2009 on Monday December 04, 2017 @05:13AM
(#15842829)
Thanks for reporting your experiences here even though this discussion ended 3 days ago(!)
My overall impressions are good! The program completely redefines my thoughts for capabilities of DOM based applications and WebGL.
Pros: Use anywhere on any device(Linux)! (DOM Based) Free for personal use. Scripting based design automation seems like first class citizens with the part monitoring and profiling features Sheet metal capabilities are easy and intuitive. Something that I can't say for Solidworks. You can straight up delete things in Onshape, Fusion 360 makes that a bit hard. I like the fact that parts and assemblies are two explicitly different things.(Solidworks does this) It makes it easier for my brain to cut the "pie". Fusion does it a more NX'y way where "a part is a part/assembly". I don't have much experience with surfacing, so I can't comment about that aspect. Git like branch/merge functionality with parts.
Cons:
It ain't the whole widget.. At the end of the day it's "just" a CAD program. Which is fine, but I feel that most consumers are getting "finer" tastes with the advent of "the whole widget" design. Thanks Apple. (I don't mean that in a negative way either.) The thing that blew my mind about Fusion 360, is that CAM is integrated and just works, CLOUD Based FEA/Rendering just works, FEA Analysis it's there, Topological optimization there too. Rendering it's there also.
OnShape's value proposition is a bit weak compared to Fusion 360.Fusion 360 is free under ($100k of revenue per year), $300 a year for basic, and $1500 a year for Ultimate. (Basic will work for like 95% of users).
OnShape is free for personal/non-commercial use and everything needs to be publicly accessible. Then to go from personal to commerical/private. It's $1500 a year...just for CAD. Want the other features that Fusion 360 has? Open your wallet...
Fusion 360 in many respects, functions as a great drug dealer. They give you a little for free. They supply more value for you, as you need it. But the pricing is never so high , where you need to make hard call, and stop using their drugs. You grow with your drug dealer. Onshape is like "Here's enough for one hit", but if you want any more than that. Here's a brick, and I won't give it in little bags so you can give it to your friends at parties. You need to do it yourself....It's also a felony if you screw up when you try to buy in big.
Here's a good use case: I'm an at home inventor that wants to do a Kickstarter/Sharktank product. With OnShape, since it's commercial I need to front $1500 a year to solve only one piece of my product pie. Then more cash after that. With Fusion 360, I pay $0. If it takes off and I make over $100k. Paying $300 bucks a year is literally not a problem.
With this use case: OnShape isn't even on the radar for a CAD product to use.
But I always root for the underdog. But they have some work to do before they can have the same impact as Solidworks when came in out in the 90's. The DOM based app is really cool, and has alot of potential. But I don't plan on doing CAD on my Pixel2. The CAD/CAM/CAE workflow matters an order of magnitude more. Here's the cool thing. All of that can be computed in the DOM, so it can be developed down the line.
For year of 2015+ products, Fusion has the crown now.