News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DOJ: We Want Martin Shkreli’s Enigma Machine, Wu-Tang Alb... by wlesieutre on Friday December 01, 2017 @08:57PM (#15829611)
But if someone seizes it from him through legal means they wouldn't be bound by that agreement, would they?
Re:DOJ: We Want Martin Shkreli’s Enigma Machine, Wu-Tang Alb... by jlgaddis on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:03PM (#15829631)
Let's say the government gets it, auctions it, you (legally) purchase it (at that auction), and are now the owner.

While you wouldn't be bound by any agreements that Shkreli had w/ Wu-Tang Clan, you would still be in violation of copyright laws if you released it publicly (and the government could, potentially, put stipulations on its sale if they wanted).

In addition, if you owned the only existing copy, I think it would be pretty easy to prove that it was you who released it.

Re:DOJ: We Want Martin Shkreli’s Enigma Machine, Wu-Tang Alb... by bogomipz on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:21PM (#15829705)
None of that is true.

Contractually, the purchaser is not allowed to release it "commercially" which means they could release it for free. It has nothing to do with any copyright laws.

>"There are strict limitations on the distribution of the 31-track double album, with a statement from the band reading: "It can be exhibited publicly and it can be given away for free. But it cannot be commercialised as a conventional album release until 2103"[1]

[1] http://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/m...

Re:DOJ: We Want Martin Shkreli’s Enigma Machine, Wu-Tang Alb... by PhasmaFelis on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:47PM (#15829816)
> Contractually, the purchaser is not allowed to release it "commercially" which means they could release it for free. It has nothing to do with any copyright laws.

Someone who buys it from a government auction is not bound by any contract signed by the original purchaser. They are still bound by copyright law, although the copyright holder (presumably Wu-Tang Clan) could (and likely would) allow them to exhibit it or give it away.

Re:DOJ: We Want Martin Shkreli’s Enigma Machine, Wu-Tang Alb... by godzillabrennus on Friday December 01, 2017 @09:01PM (#15829625)
I don't think they would. That'd be an interesting legal matter to see play out.