Re:Uber's use of encrypted messaging may set legal precedents
by icebraining on Friday December 01, 2017 @06:18PM
(#15828657)
You can, but pleading the Fifth on a civil case can be held against you (adverse inference). IANAL as well.
Depending on which Federal circuit applies, and how you authenticate to your device, only if they already had proof that your messages were material to the case. Unlocking your device (with a passcode or password, as distinct from biometrics) has been ruled to be "testimonial", so the State must have specific knowledge that your iMessage has inculpatory evidence in order to compel you to unlock it and hand those messages over.
(IANAL.)