News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two Envelopes Problem by _delirium on Friday August 06, 2010 @07:48PM (#1582666)
Under a frequentist interpretation of probability that's correct (and the paradox doesn't arise), but Bayesian decision theory does allow you to reason in the way the paradox proposes, starting in a situation where you've already picked an envelope, and estimating the utility of switching to the other one by multiplying the probability that you're in the high->low configuration with the value of a high->low switch, and likewise with a low->high switch. So you have 50% chance of halving your money, 50% of doubling, and thus estimated 1.25x return.

Frequentist probability doesn't let you do that, because it doesn't let you say "there's a 50% likelihood I'm in this state, and 50% that I'm in the other". Instead, it says you must be in one or the other state (non-probabilistically), and the probabilities are only attached to a previous process that generated that outcome. But Bayesian probability does let you interpret the probabilities as belief in each current state, so you have a 50% belief you're in one state, and a 50% belief you're in the other, and the value of any decision is thus 0.5 * value_if_I_was_in_situation_A + 0.5 * value_if_I_was_in_situation_B.

(If you don't allow that kind of computation, Bayesian decision theory has to be revised in some other cases as well.)

Re:Two Envelopes Problem by john7 on Friday August 06, 2010 @08:22PM (#1582742)
No, Bayesian decision theory does not allow you to reason in that way.

Suppose the amounts in the envelopes are A and B. A Bayesian would say:

Prob(I have A) = 1/2 and Prob(I have B) = 1/2

The expected gain from switching is:

Prob(I have A)x(what I'd gain from switching = B-A) + Prob(I have B)x(what I'd gain from switching = A-B)

which is: 1/2 x (B-A) + 1/2 x (A-B) = 0

Re:Two Envelopes Problem by _delirium on Friday August 06, 2010 @08:33PM (#1582767)
Ah yes, this one can be solved that way; oops. My understanding of the literature is that variants are much more problematic, though, and require more complex restrictions on typical Bayesian probability frameworks to exorcise them.

This is one good review, with a proposed solution (from a Bayesian perspective): http://books.google.com/books?id=14_ykEOAZ6AC&pg=PA49