Re:Show HN: Shazam-like acoustic fingerprinting of continuou...
by ssalazar on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @05:14PM
(#15811396)
Spectrograms are a convenient way to visualize the data/algorithm but are rarely part of the actual analysis.
They are already using the 2d array so to speak.
In any case a spectrogram is just a 2d array where the magnitude of each array element is mapped to a color, so its effectively the same thing.
Few if any people use visual representations of sound for analysis, except for the crazies who run spectrograms though visual deep learning networks.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Show HN: Shazam-like acoustic fingerprinting of continuou...
by dest on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @05:24PM
(#15811468)
Uh, are you sure of what you are writing here? Time-frequency analysis (including spectrograms) is one of the very fundamental tools for signal processing.
Re:Show HN: Shazam-like acoustic fingerprinting of continuou...
by ssalazar on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @05:52PM
(#15811655)
True, i was thinking of a spectrogram as purely a visualization of a time-series of DFTs but Matlab and other tools do not make this distinction.
I was mainly responding to the OP's distinction between analyzing a visual representation and analyzing a "2d array" when they are basically the same thing.
Re:Show HN: Shazam-like acoustic fingerprinting of continuou...
by throwmenow_0140 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:24PM
(#15812226)
> analyzing a visual representation and analyzing a "2d array" when they are basically the same thing.
This is what I mean. I guess their tooling just outputs graphics and it's easier to work with those than the pure 2d array in numpy or something similar.