Re:Life's unfair? Do something Or just get used to it.
by Tichy on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:20AM
(#1580919)
I think it is just wrong to assume that social security exists because people are so good in their hearts and like being taken advantage of. Probably many (the majority) thinks so, but in reality, it is simply a form of insurance. Also, I pay up to keep the beggars and robbers off the street. That is a purely selfish reason - I think solid political systems should be based on selfishness.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Life's unfair? Do something Or just get used to it.
by rick888 on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:49AM
(#1580983)
" Also, I pay up to keep the beggars and robbers off the street."
More social programs just create a lower class that has a lifetime dependence on the government for money. It also doesn't seem to lower the crime rate. Detroit is a good example of this. There were more social programs and money pumped into that city than any other, yet the murder rate is #2 in the US.
Re:Life's unfair? Do something Or just get used to it.
by adin on Friday August 06, 2010 @12:29PM
(#1581490)
It also doesn't seem to lower the crime rate. [...] There were more social programs and money pumped into that city than any other, yet the murder rate is #2 in the US.
This should be pretty obvious to most HN readers, but I'm reminding people anyway. "Correlation does not imply causation".
Re:Life's unfair? Do something Or just get used to it.
by Tichy on Friday August 06, 2010 @06:44PM
(#1582552)
Social programs are not the same thing as social insurance. I am happy to live in a country where the amount of violence that seems to be normal in the US is still inconceivable.
Re:Life's unfair? Do something Or just get used to it.
by dan00 on Friday August 06, 2010 @09:33AM
(#1580941)
"I think solid political systems should be based on selfishness."
This can't work, because there's no end in selfishness. If you're more selfish than others, than you will have an advantage, as long the others are a bit less selfish.
At the end selfishness harms itself.
Re:Life's unfair? Do something Or just get used to it.
by Tichy on Friday August 06, 2010 @10:38AM
(#1581123)
If you are too selfish, society will cast you out. So it is selfish to not be too selfish. I don't mean everybody should be as selfish as possible, just that society should be a net win. Granted, it is more difficult than it sounds.