News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by eeks on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:32AM (#15807516)
<quote> My goals are pretty easy to understand, but grand in scope (more fun that way, eh?): to build a global, multilingual, high quality, neutral news service. </quote>

There is no such things as neutral news. But you can strive for some good, honest reporting with high journalistic standards.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by tyrust on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @03:21PM (#15810484)
>There is no such things as neutral news.

That's a big statement, can you elaborate?

Surely there can be objective reporting on events. So do you mean that filtration that a news organization must perform (i.e. it's impossible to report on every event) will have some bias?

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @03:41PM (#15810636)
Every algorithm for promoting certain articles over others favors some groups over others. Even if you evaluate on neutral grounds, you're still favoring the groups that are in fact able to get you to consider things as news (eg, news wire services, active contributors, etc).
Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by tyrust on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @03:56PM (#15810766)
>Every algorithm for promoting certain articles over others favors some groups over others.

You could present articles in chronological order.

>you're still favoring the groups that are in fact able to get you to consider things as news

Yeah, that's essentially what I was saying.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by ThrustVectoring on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:46PM (#15811153)
Let me elaborate and be more concrete. Suppose a special interest group - say, Comcast's PR team - wants your organization to consider their press release as "news". Either you accept their claim of newsworthiness and have more of a "for" slant, or reject or modify their claim and have more of an "anti" slant.

Or another example: the website itself is far easier to contribute to with stable electrical supply, broadband internet access, and an ample supply of free time. You can bet that the news is going to be more relevant to white-collar first-world educated folks than subsistence farmers in rural India. I mean, yeah, Indian subsistence farmers could contribute in principle, but in practice, you're going to get a lot of news suggestions from other folks, and those suggestions are going to wind up as news articles.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by atondwal on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:44PM (#15812330)
You just put together the clearest examples I've seen for illustrating this point. When it need to make it from now on, I'm linking to this comment :)
Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by tyrust on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:56PM (#15811233)
Your first paragraph is, again, essentially what I initially stated.

Your second paragraph is a separate, and good, point.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by Cyberdog on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:40AM (#15807600)
Seeing how poorly Wikipedia succeeds at neutrality much of the time, I don't have much hope this project will do any better.
Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by alexandercrohde on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:50AM (#15807689)
What are you benchmarking against?

As compared to what you'll read in published books on the shelf (which seem to write whatever they feel like) or even mainstream media or even the average professor, I think wikipedia does an outstanding job.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by waynecochran on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:51AM (#15807700)
You can't create what can't exist. Neutrality at best is just presenting as many different (credible) views as possible, but usually contains a "straw man" or two.
Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by msla on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:29AM (#15808055)
As Wikipedia defines it, anyway, neutrality is biased towards the current scientific consensus, which cuts down on the fringe content and makes the supporters of things like homeopathy very, very angry: They think neutrality should mean "every position gets taken equally seriously", which is false balance, and go a bit berserk when Wikipedia's rules make the homeopathy article largely anti-homeopathy, by presenting the best current knowledge as fact and presenting homeopathy itself as discredited.

There's no way to have a coherent, readable article which is philosophically neutral. Good thing Wikipedia doesn't try.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by glenstein on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:45PM (#15813056)
This is a very important point. The problem with satisfying people's desires for neutrality is that people have incompatible, often incoherent ideas about what neutrality is supposed to be.

Naturally, some people don't like Wikipedia's version of neutrality, though I happen to think it's quite a good one: neutral in its reflection of what reliable sources say, not substantively neutral on subject matter. So I'm not particularly troubled by the problem as it pertains to WikiTribune.

The fact that some people don't like their notion of neutrality isn't a problem with them in particular, so much as an inevitability that reflects the way people with incompatible opinions will react to any possible version of neutrality. So the question should be which among the notions of neutrality that will inevitably anger some people is the most preferable.

Re:Hello, world: this is WikiTribune by alecco on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:12PM (#15810902)
By neutral he means aligned with his own biases.