I would love to see some references to privacy laws that fit the situation. I think most of them come in the form of apartment landlord -> occupant, not occupant -> occupant. I think people really need to look carefully at what these laws actually say because I doubt any of the hotel laws and most of the renter laws actually apply.
Re:Hidden Cameras in AirBnBs
by maxerickson on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:19AM
(#15807395)
It's not a stretch that the bedroom and bathroom of a rental would fall under this law, for example:
http://codes.findlaw.com/tx/penal-code/penal-sect-21-15.html
The definition isn't about the rental arrangement, just the use of the room.
I don't know if I would rely on this one. Its about changing rooms (with a very specific definition) and bath rooms. A camera in the living room would probably not trigger the law. You might be there with the bedroom, but I wonder if that law would be triggered by a private security system for the home owner.
Re:Hidden Cameras in AirBnBs
by maxerickson on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @10:39AM
(#15807583)
I'm pretty sure privacy laws would apply to a simply invited guest; "you can change in there". I wouldn't be surprised if they applied to illicit recordings of a spouse...
People enjoy strong rights in their own homes, they don't trump every right someone else may have.
but it's not an "occupant->occupant" relationship when one occupant is paying the other (aka "the owner"), with whom they have had no meaningful prior relationship, for the privilege of staying in this place for a day or two. That is by definition a stranger, and a landlord.
It would be, but AirBnB's legality and where it fits in are constantly under dispute. If the jurisdiction has short term rental laws that fit, then yes its landlord -> occupant, but many places that rent AirBnB are not legally allowed in the first place. The law is different than common sense.
For a home, they are based on whether there is a reasonable expectation of privacy. People have a reasonable expectation of privacy in pretty much any bedroom intended for their use.