I'm not really sure an AirBnB would be any less safe then a previous small boutique licensed private hotel/bnb, these also operated out of peoples homes or even larger hotels for that matter. Basically anyone can gain access to a hotel and wait for your to leave your room and break in or assault you as you enter/exit.
At least with AirBnB you can leave reviews that are easily read by potential future guests.
That said, AirBnB seems like a great example of a business that many would have thought impossible because of various kinds of social risks -- sexual assault, theft, etc. -- yet, with care taken, human decency prevails.