News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by djhworld on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:10AM (#15806461)
This is what worries me a bit about browser extensions like 1 password and other password managers.

Could a website that has a keylogger in it potentially pick up these keystrokes when I put my password into an extension?

Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by plif on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:33AM (#15806576)
No. They only have access to anything inputted within their site's window.

I think this article is a bit sensationalist. These sites already have access to all of your data (stored in their databases!). There's nothing additional they are gaining from this aside from how you input that data. That is much less sensitive information and I can't think of another usage aside from improving their site's UX.

Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by djhworld on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:56AM (#15806754)
Is there a risk of information leakage?

Say for example a website asks me for something (e.g. an address, phone number, bank account number), I type it in (thus registering my keystroke presses to the keylogger) and then realise oops I didn't mean to type that, I meant to type something else

Does the website then submit the logged keystrokes for offline analysis?

Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by plif on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @09:59AM (#15807227)
Yes, theoretically in the case you mentioned.

All responsible implementations of this won't actually log PII. It's pretty trivial to withhold certain inputs. All of the services mentioned in the article have easy ways to flag an input field as private / do not log. I'd wager a lot of money that these sites are interested in gathering UX data and not scraping for accidental form input.

I suppose there's a certain level of trust involved, but I don't think that's any different than when you make an online purchase. /shrug

Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by notzorbo3 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:52AM (#15806724)
> These sites already have access to all of your data (stored in their databases!)

The assumption for most people is going to be that they have the data that you explicitly sent them. Implicitly gathering and sending data is equivalent to snooping on people without consent. It's all about expectations.

Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by notzorbo3 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:51AM (#15806711)
> Could a website that has a keylogger in it potentially pick up these keystrokes

Yes of course. All it takes is misclicking and having the focus on a wrong window, and you're toast.

Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by haquistiona on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:19PM (#15810956)
Can you explain this more? What do you mean by "focus"?
Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by notzorbo3 on Thursday November 30, 2017 @03:45AM (#15814306)
By "focus" i mean the current window on your desktop that has the focus, as in, the one that's going to receive the input you give through your keyboard. I've seen plenty of people (and it's happened to me too) fumble and accidentally type or paste things in the wrong window. If that window happens to be your browser on a website that does this kind of tracking, that information goes to some random third party instead of the window you thought it was going to.
Re:Hundreds of web firms record 'every keystroke' by danenania on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @11:48AM (#15808280)
The risk is actually the other way around. A page can't access data in an extension, but extensions with full permissions (most of them) can access anything on any page.

Hacking a popular extension is one of the easiest routes to fully compromising millions of users (and every account they own). People are generally unaware of this danger, but it's much worse than ads or tracking.