News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @03:33PM (#15801219)
Bad conclusion. There are billions of 'other planets' and only one Earth. You'd have to add up the marginal probabilities of all the other scenarios, to compare with just the Earth scenario.
Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @03:53PM (#15801471)
But of those billions of other planets, as they get further and further away, the probability of an asteroid from them finding Earth goes down. So does the probability of life on the asteroid surviving the trip.

I think that the number of planets within a distance R is O(R^2), but the probability of an asteroid from such a planet reaching us is O(1/R^2). But if the probability of life on the asteroid surviving the trip decreases with a longer trip, the net effect is probably that the further-away planets contribute little to the probability of life reaching us in this way.

Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:56PM (#15802223)
The panspermia idea is, that it started somewhere and somewhen, and has been planet hopping ever since. We only need one nearby life-bearing planet to seed earth; it got seeded from further away and so on.

Similar to how ancient Romans wore silk but didn't have trade with China. It only took each trader to trade with their neighbor, and silk could travel thousands of miles.

Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:20PM (#15802419)
OK, but at that point, the "billions of planets out there" argument doesn't work. You're left with the probability of it transferring from a nearby planet.
Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:23PM (#15802440)
Right, and the inevitability of it being present in a nearby planet went way up. Because once it started somewhere (and there are billions of 'somewheres') it would spread like a virus and infect every possible receptive environment.

The statistics is hard. No simple counting of planets is enough. All the vectors have to be accounted for.

Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:50PM (#15802661)
No, the inevitability of it being present in a nearby planet went way up if the probability of it moving from one planet to another planet is decently high - and not otherwise.
Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @08:52AM (#15806717)
Probability is over time. With enough time (billions of years?), the total probability approaches 1.0.
Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by AnimalMuppet on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @12:38PM (#15808924)
No, it doesn't. If the probability per year is 10^-15, then the probability over 10 billion years (10^10) is still 10^-5. (I mean, yes, over a quadrillion years the probability approaches 1.0, but I don't think that helps your position.)

You keep trying to say "but big numbers of planets, and big amounts of time" to make this idea reasonable. But it doesn't work. You have to deal with how low the probability actually is of it happening from one planet in one year. If that's low enough, you can't salvage it just by saying "billions of years and billions of planets".

Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by JoeAltmaier on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:04PM (#15810823)
...and you can't refute it by making up tiny numbers. Statistics is hard and you can be fooled by big/small numbers. Until some reasonable estimate of the actually probability of an asteroid making it from one system to another (oh look! There's one in our system now!) you can't make conclusions.
Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by antonvs on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:20PM (#15801833)
> You'd have to add up the marginal probabilities of all the other scenarios, to compare with just the Earth scenario.

There aren't even close to billions of other planets that could have been candidates for sending a life-bearing asteroid to Earth. Some of the restrictions are:

1. A planet capable of having developed life.

2. A planet close enough for an asteroid from it (I have trouble typing that because it's such an unlikely scenario) to have reached Earth around the time that life on Earth began. That was ~4 billion years ago, which seems like a lot, but consider that if the recently spotted asteroid 1I/2017 U1 had come direct to us from Proxima Centauri, the closest star, it would have taken at least 48,000 years to get here. That puts a limit on candidate sources of less than 100 times the distance to Proxima, and limits the number of star systems to ~2 million.

Even if you multiply the probabilities in question by a factor of 1e6 to 1e7, it's not going to change the conclusion.

Re:Bacteria on the outside of the International Space Station by JoeAltmaier on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:52PM (#15802176)
Add in : asteroids in close orbits around suns developing life elsewhere (or here). Precursor chemicals to life surviving the asteroid trip even if whole organisms do not (accelerating life development on Earth by millions/a billion years).

We started with, it took an Earth to develop life, but if it came from elsewhere we'd have to expand our ideas to include all other possible sources of life, not just Earthlike. Because our premise changed.