News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Freak_NL on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:39AM (#15797607)
Does it though? Ten years ago it was trivial to surf to your local bay of pirates and get a copy of just about any popular film or series. This is still possible (hypothetically of course), but it takes a lot more effort (finding and joining trustworthy private trackers or setting up newsgroups), precaution (VPN, OPSEC), and diligence.

But that's not because DRM works.

Getting a digital copy of some bit of media is still trivial. Netflix forcing its DRM on its customers doesn't mean that you can't illegally download Stranger Things in excellent quality, and their DRM doesn't slow anyone dedicated to doing so down at all.

In fact, Netflix could stream all their stuff without DRM, and nothing would change (with one exception I'll come to in a bit). What's made piracy harder is a combination of factors:

* The legal way is often easier (just pay Netflix a small monthly sum and watch stuff)

* The legal way suffices for a lot of people

* Getting caught infringing copyright has serious consequences in many countries

* Downloading files from shady sources puts your computer at risk (Windows in particular; e.g., ransomware)

If Netflix turned off all their DRM tomorrow, then perhaps some pirates would have a slightly easier way to source their material, but otherwise nothing would change.

Except that the end-user gets a better experience.

At this moment Netflix is refusing to serve 1080p video content to anyone who uses a free operating system and free browser, because 'the DRM isn't good enough'. For 4k the rules are even more stringent; you need Microsoft Windows, Edge, and pre-approved trusted-platform capable hardware (which includes the monitor/TV).

For the rest of us, Netflix and the major content studios begrudgingly allow us to watch 720p video on our way too open computers.

This isn't about protecting the media streams from piracy, this is about making sure that the future of media consumption means consumers will run the media producers' software, using their rules, on hardware they control. We are not supposed to run our own HTPC, or do clever things with media we pay for (e.g., letting an algorithm watch ahead to warn the user of scenes with strobe light effects for epileptic patients, as the EFF mentions, or simply controlling a string of LED lights behind your screen for added effect, or downloading the streams to watch on holiday, or cut fragments out of a stream to use as samples in a lawful manner (e.g., a blog about films, or some cultural analysis), or …).

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by gear54rus on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:32AM (#15798091)
> At this moment Netflix is refusing to server 1080p video content to anyone who uses a free operating system and free browser, because 'the DRM isn't good enough'. For 4k the rules are even more stringent; you need Microsoft Windows, Edge, and pre-approved trusted-platform capable hardware (which includes the monitor/TV).

Hahahah, amazes me how people still use that crap. Why not pirate it instead and give them a big fuck you with those restrictions?

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Freak_NL on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:23AM (#15798609)
Because it is a fiendish dilemma. Most people are fine to obligingly use proprietary apps on approved operating systems to gain access to the content, so if you care about remunerating content producers, and watching the media by means of open technologies that work on any modern operating system, then supporting Netflix is currently one way to do so.

But you are right, the downside is that my account is effectively limited to 720p because of complete non-sense.

The sad thing is that any competition (e.g., Amazon Prime) appears to follow the same rules as far as I can tell: sure, you can use your browser, for now, but nothing over 720p for you until you run our software outside of that sandbox of a browser on a verified trusted operating system.

I'm not sure where my point of rejection of this deal lies.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by andrepd on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:34AM (#15798740)
That's what I do, with zero remorse. They are killing the web to make bigger sacks of money. Fuck me if I'm going to feel bad about pirating the everliving shit out of their content.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by briandear on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:25AM (#15798630)
So stealing is ok? Who pays for that content you pirate?
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by quadrangle on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @03:22PM (#15801092)
It's freeriding not stealing. Same sense as burglary is not murder or as obnoxiousness isn't assault etc.

So freeriding is ok? Who pays for creating that content you enjoy?

See, now we have a useful phrasing that actually can be discussed and brings up real issues.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by andrepd on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @11:35AM (#15798744)
Copying is not stealing.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by khedoros1 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:07PM (#15801645)
I've never deprived someone of something they own or committed any kind of mayhem on the high sea.

Generally, I pay for whatever content I download. I'd have to do some research to figure out how to rip a Netflix stream or export recorded video from my DVR. Ripping DVDs (and especially Blu-Rays) takes a bunch of time, and encoding the result can be hard to get right (embedding subtitles, choosing a codec and profile that works on most of my devices, etc). It's easier and faster to torrent it than do all the ripping and conversion myself. Not that I do it much anymore; I suspect that format-shifting wouldn't be a good legal defense. And I also suspect that my ISP (the only high-speed one in the area) would dump me as a customer at some point.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by posterboy on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @03:41AM (#15805506)
> embedding subtitles

shame on you, good thing you aren't doing it either way ;)

> I suspect that format-shifting wouldn't be a good legal defense

you seem to imply by analogy to homerecording, torrenting stuff you once payed for (or didn't directly as with yt) might be ok, but sure enough, taperecordings were campaigned against, too.

Btw: I worry about codec and network exploits, so easy is not the exact term I would choose wrt torrents and p2p-"sharing".

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by khedoros1 on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @02:12PM (#15809828)
> shame on you, good thing you aren't doing it either way ;)

srt's in the container, not hard-overlaid into the video ;-) We've got asshole neighbors. They'll purposefully rev their Ferrari to wake my kid up if they hear the TV (e.g. sound is up enough to easily understand a whispered conversation, then there's a bass-heavy explosion). Then there's the less-common use-case of watching a movie on a plane without blasting the audio.

> you seem to imply by analogy to homerecording, torrenting stuff you once payed for (or didn't directly as with yt) might be ok, but sure enough, taperecordings were campaigned against, too.

Tape recordings don't involve automatic sharing of the data with other people in the swarm as an implementation detail. I did a fair amount of downloading 8-15 years ago, but mostly dropped it when I started working.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by saas_co_de on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:45AM (#15798231)
It is far easier to access pirated media today and with far higher quality than 10 years ago.

The kids are using unlicensed streaming sites and get anything they want in the browser at the click of a button.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by annabellish on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @09:57AM (#15797747)
Huh? It's still trivial to pirate media. Grab a copy of the Tor browser, go to the same pirate bay you used ten years ago, download the same content you did then. Zero investment, it's just as straightforward.

The legal options have improved, but the illegal ones are still there and just as good.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by Freak_NL on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:04AM (#15797825)
That's trivial to us (hypothetically), not to the average consumer who is, quite frankly, well-advised not to risk getting 'fined' in an out-of-court settlement for infringing copyright. And how do they even know if they're on the real Piratebay? The original domains are blocked in many countries. TOR? VPN? These require knowledge or guidance; doable, but not zero investment.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by AlexandrB on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:15AM (#15797952)
> That's trivial to us (hypothetically), not to the average consumer who is, quite frankly, well-advised not to risk getting 'fined' in an out-of-court settlement for infringing copyright.

Pirating content has gotten SO easy that my elderly parents do it regularly by simply searching for streams of movies they want to see on google. DRM has stopped none of this - and the risks of getting drive-by malware are an afterthought to most people.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by nicoburns on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:31AM (#15798078)
It's actually far easier to pirate media now. No need to setup a torrent client at all. Simply browse to one of the hundreds of free streaming sites and download over http directly in your browser.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by flukus on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @01:31AM (#15805051)
The average person now get's dozens/hundreds of movies and shows on a cheap USB stick from their friends, then the plug it into their TV to play. Piracy is easier for the average consumer now than it ever was in the past.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by TYPE_FASTER on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:15PM (#15799816)
Search Craigslist for "kodi" and find pre-configured devices for sale to access pirated content.

This is dangerous, because I'm not sure the people buying them understand that the content is pirated...

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by ryanlol on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:06AM (#15797848)
If you can google, you can find a mirror or a clone.

Whether it is the real pirate bay or not doesn’t matter, you could never trust TPB.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by on_and_off on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:52PM (#15800182)
why is that ?
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by ryanlol on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @02:34PM (#15800610)
Why is what? You can find things with google because it's a search engine, that's what it's for.

You can't trust TPB because the content is user generated, TPB does not do much to stop people from uploading malicious content and boosting it to top10 by seeding with bots.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by fixermark on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:55AM (#15798335)
Nothing that involves "Tor" fits the "trivial" definition.

If Netflix captures the market of people who aren't comfortable subverting encryption, they win. 100% capture is unnecessary if they get the people who can't and intimidate the people who won't with the occasional prosecution of the people who do.

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by romwell on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @06:45PM (#15803140)
Right, that's why there's usually no need to bother with Tor.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by drdaeman on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:55PM (#15800204)
Not exactly correct.

The illegal ones are not "just as good" - they faced the competition and got better in the past few years, learning from others successes.

Remember the Popcorn Time. It dropped a bomb because it was an evolution from "go to some tracker, find what you want, download it, wait, watch when it's done" to the modern standards of "think of a title, grab the popcorn and start watching".

(Just in case - I'm not approving or condemning of anything. Just stating the facts what had happened.)

Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by ryanlol on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:05AM (#15797836)
Why Tor browser?
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by durzagott on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @10:59AM (#15798380)
Maybe to bypass local blacklisting? For example, in the UK major ISPs block access to the popular torrent sites.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by ryanlol on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @02:35PM (#15800614)
There are countless mirrors, Tor browser seems like a hassle.
Re:DRM’s Dead Canary: How We Lost the Web, What We Learned, ... by YSFEJ4SWJUVU6 on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:07PM (#15801647)
>For the rest of us, Netflix and the major content studios begrudgingly allow us to watch 720p video on our way too open computers.

I wish they even gave this, but at least in here, many mainstream flicks are of even worse quality (although this restriction on some content seems to apply even on Windows and Edge browser, at least on my computers). Not that it really matters what's the nominal resolution of a 1000 kbps stream anyway (and lately Netflix has removed the option to see the actual resolution of the video I think), however...

... selling out the free web got us so much indeed.