Re:Bitcoin Bubble Makes Dot-Com Look Rational
by dmichulke on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @07:08AM
(#15796464)
You are deflecting to a problem of definition ;)
Yes, you have the same amount but no it doesn't purchase as much as it did one year ago. Units of accounting only make sense within a context of other units of account.
A dollar by itself is just a piece of paper if you cannot buy an amount of wheat, water or square meters with it.
And by that measure the dollar is losing value vs a bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin Bubble Makes Dot-Com Look Rational
by csomar on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @07:12AM
(#15796483)
So? You just repeated what I said. My original comment was debunking the Bloomberg article.
When you hold 1 Stock, at the end of the year you get a dividend. You divide the dividend by the stock to get the P/E ratio.
That's not the same with USD or BTC. Its value fluctuates but it generates no income on its own.
Holding 1 USD will give you 1 USD after 1 year.
Holding 1 Bitcoin will give you 1 Bitcoin after 1 year.
You are confusing the unit you are holding with the value "vs" another unit. That depends on the market and the external factors (like inflation, interest rates, etc...)
But holding 1 Unit will always give you 1 Unit of whatever you are holding.