News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Future of Startup Funding by stevenbedrick on Thursday August 05, 2010 @06:57PM (#1579606)
As always, PG's done a good job of writing a thought-provoking and highly readable essay. I'm hardly qualified to comment one way or another about the ins and outs of startup financing- I'm willing to assume that he's got the facts right on those aspects of the essay- but one part of the essay stuck out at me like a sore thumb: (talking about YCombinator's "competition" with employers)

<blockquote> Nearly all customers choose the competing product, a job. Why? Well, let's look at the product we're offering. An unbiased review would go something like this:

Starting a startup gives you more freedom and the opportunity to make a lot more money than a job, but it's also hard work and at times very stressful. </blockquote>

I'd say that this represents about 80% of an "unbiased review". The missing 20%? "... it's also hard work, and at times very stressful, <em>and the odds are very much against all of that hard work and stress paying off for you in any kind of direct, financial way.</em>"

Re:The Future of Startup Funding by pg on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:18PM (#1579657)
I wouldn't put that in the product review because it's more a feature of the user than the product.

E.g. it wouldn't be accurate to say in a product review of running shoes "you are going to run slow in these shoes" even if on average that's what people did.

Re:The Future of Startup Funding by Eliezer on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:03AM (#1580502)
Who, considering working their first startup job, can possibly end up in an epistemic state of knowing that their hard work will pay off? How could you reasonably end up assigning a confidence of more than 50% without it being sheer naked Lake Wobegon effect and overconfidence? If no one can possibly get rid of this uncertainty, it ought to be part of the unbiased review.
Re:The Future of Startup Funding by pbiggar on Friday August 06, 2010 @10:05AM (#1581030)
In case I'm reading too much into this, am I right in think that you believe startups are _not_ risky?

If so, then that changes nearly everything that people understand about startups.

Re:The Future of Startup Funding by pg on Monday August 09, 2010 @02:02PM (#1588768)
I'm saying that while there is a large random multiplier in everyone's outcome, the risk of total failure varies enormously with the founders. Some founders have a near 0% chance of total failure. Others (a larger number) have a near 100% chance. So while this means on average the change of a startup succeeding is 1/n, quoting that stat as part of the description of a startup would be misleading, because for a small number of people it's just not true, just as for a small number of fast runners it would not be true that they'd run slow in the shoes, whatever the average person did.