1) The go with touch bolted onto Windows on x86. While it's understandable that they'd like to carry along a base of existing software, what are the chances of the interface working well? The CES demo didn't seem to show any more touch than flipping through pages in an e-reader someone else wrote. The lack of OS features and other apps to show off was very telling. It's doubtful many are surprised that HP hasn't shipped yet.
There's been touch support in Windows since XP, but as an add-on, how can it being anything but an awful kludge?
Even if they succeed with a Windows offering, it is apt to be a failure in the sense that it'd just be cannibalizing their own netbook/laptop sales. Vendors do seem to be waiting for Intel to ship a lower power x86 part, so a Windows kludge seems to be the most likely path.
2) They could go with something new... run on another CPU (different instruction set) porting some frameworks from Windows but using a new U.I. Can they pull off a great touch U.I? Can they write code that'll deliver speedy performance and good battery life with a low-power CPU? Can they write a few great core apps and make the platform attractive to developers? (They've got no phone to migrate an alternative base from). Can they out-Apple Apple?
I don't think it's the competition that's going to be scared of big old Microsoft... more likely the users and developers, and to a lesser degree the stockholders.
With something new, a so-so offering would fail big time. (Think Zune). It'd really have to offer something Apple doesn't. If lower price is the only draw, it may get sales without making anybody any money. Apple has room to cut prices if they want to.
Having picked up Palm and WebOS and BeOS, I think HP has a better chance of cooking up a viable tablet OS (and hardware bundle) than MS and other partners.
Personally, I consider that a failure. Even in the poop brown colour people still assume it is an iPod.
I don’t see how that can be called success.
Ballmer may be doing a Jobs. "Nobody reads anymore"... well not until I release iBooks that is.
At this point there is so little reason to play their tablet hand if it is WP7. They already have 3rd parties working on apps. The only thing they'd get is scrutiny.
Update: This is basically exactly what the TechFlash article referred to in another comment says.
The question is: are any of these platforms actually successful? If Microsoft “got it”, wouldn’t there be some notable successes here among all the failures? Wouldn’t the company be able to make something other than Windows and Office reasonably profitable, if they truly understood where technology was going and what users wanted?
And even WinMo came out and did match their chief competitor at the time, Palm OS.
The problem isn't that they can't make products successful -- Zune makes a profit. It's that they need to make a profit that moves the bottomline, which is hard if you have Windows and Office.
The problem (from my consumer perspective) is that Microsoft’s existence (at least for the last 15 years) doesn’t result in any products that are fundamentally better than those that would have been around anyway. The comparison to Apple (the original topic here) is like night to day.
Lets take Excel as an example. What is a superior spreadsheet to Excel today? It is by far the easiest spreadsheet that I've used. Much easier than Google's or Open Office's. Plus has capabilities that neither has. For example, check out its support for pivot tables and pivot charts, including accessing RDBMS and OLAP stores. And with PowerPivot now supports GB in memory warehouses. Really, give me a spreadsheet that can do what Excel can do, yet I can give it to a 10 year old kid and they can keep their batting average tracked in it?
And don't forget that Excel and Word (and the rest of Office) come with powerful addin models. I've seen companies build their entire workflow in Office. Something you simply can't do with any other product in the market.
Sure Excel may not be innovating in the sense that it doesn't have an external antenna. But there's a reason that people pay money for it, despite these free products. And its not because they're idiots. It's because when you actually stack up the apps, and look at the features, Excel kills it. And Excel 2010 adds a LOT of new features that paying customers want (and have asked for). Sure, I don't expect the 10 year old kid who is tracking his RBIs to care about about new built-in calculations or embedded filters in charts, or no PIA deployment, but for people who demand a lot of their spreadsheets, it can't be beat.
And you don't think Kinect is a little innovative? Really? Sure, maybe not your cup of tea, but if people are falling all over themselves for the iPhone 4's gyroscope you have to give MS a little props for Kinect (not to mention XBox Live).
Microsoft’s strategy would be completely different if they “got it”. They would’ve taken their billions of dollars in the bank, and hired a team of people who could get a new platform built. They’d have set internal expectations high, and kept a tight focus on meeting real needs with an interface that could delight users.
I think the individual technical expertise probably exists somewhere inside Microsoft: they do all kinds of neat research, and employ plenty of smart people. Evidently, though, the institutional structure of Microsoft, with competing teams vying for resources and squabbling over areas of perceived overlapping expertise, has prevented them from executing.
In my opinion, everything Microsoft has done over the last 5-10 years (if not forever) has been a game of catch-up, trying to copy competitors when they see those competitors as more successful, and seldom if ever really innovating, at least not in shipping products. The Microsoft product vision seems myopic and incoherent.