News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by WalterBright on Monday November 27, 2017 @07:10PM (#15793049)
I wish SpaceX was traded on the stock exchange so I could buy stock in it. I had to settle for buying some TSLA.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Matt3o12_ on Monday November 27, 2017 @07:31PM (#15793172)
I am glad that they are not. While I would like to invest in them, them being public would mean that Elon has to spend a lot of time doing what investors want (making the most money) instead of doing what he envisions the company to do (going to mars). There is a reason Elon regret ps that Tesla is public but it was the only way it could have survived.

By staying private, Elon can choose whom to allows to invest in so that the missions stays what he wants it to be. It’d rather not make money from SpaceX then have them going on the wrong path and become yet another government competing space company that does little innovation and just sucks up government money.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by elihu on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:34PM (#15793505)
I think there's a bigger danger to becoming a profit-centered publicly traded company than just them not innovating.

The character of future society on Mars will in large part depend on the policies of the large corporations that provide the technology and infrastructure to make it possible, and I would rather that Mars society looks like a diverse, free, liberal democracy with reasonable opportunities for homesteading and an efficient economy with multiple competing vendors for various resources and not like a forced labor camp where you work your 80 hours a week in exchange for the CO2 filters you need to survive, or like a tourist destination where one company owns the whole Mars Experience.

In the short term it's probably inevitable that one company will have a transportation-to-Mars monopoly, but if that company has some good founding principles and a vision that doesn't involve milking every last dime out of their monopoly status, then I can at least feel a little better that Mars has a chance of not becoming a dystopia.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by WalterBright on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:17PM (#15793427)
Unfortunately, the amount I'm capable of investing in SpaceX is not worth Elon's time, so appealing to him is not going to work. I just want a piece of the action in one of the greatest ventures of our time!

Lots of people complain about how unfair it is that the US has billionaires, but without billionaires would we have SpaceX? I doubt it.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by lmm on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @06:31AM (#15796224)
> Lots of people complain about how unfair it is that the US has billionaires, but without billionaires would we have SpaceX? I doubt it.

A thousand million-dollar startups can probably do more innovation between them than one billion-dollar startup. Maybe we would've ended up with a different structure - maybe one company would make a better engine and sell it to Boeing or whoever, and another would make better structural components, and another would come up with the landing systems by licensing control systems from yet another... but I think without billionaires (and remember Musk is one billionaire of many, he's by no means the median example) we'd get more value for society overall.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by WalterBright on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:45PM (#15802615)
We already have tens of thousands of million-dollar startups. None of them started a space program.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by lmm on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @04:53AM (#15805737)
SpaceX hasn't started a space program. They've launched satellites for customers and fulfilled a NASA contract for resupply to the ISS.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:54AM (#15796073)
There's a distinction though. Billionaires are people, identities, faces you can love or hate depending on what they do, but investments like these are done by faceless corporations. I don't mind corporations to have billions, spacex, tesla, apple, etc all have that and they can use that money for investing in Stuff.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by erikpukinskis on Monday November 27, 2017 @09:39PM (#15793830)
There's no way Elon will take it public unless he absolutely has to. He said this about Tesla earlier this year:

"I wish we could be private with Tesla. It actually makes us less efficient to be a public company." - https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/features/elon-musk-inve...

The stock market news cycle is a constant barrage of criticism every quarter: commentary on whether they made some random analyst's projections, investors asking the same inane questions over and over... How many times has he given the "there's no point in giving you delivery estimates for specific months because the ramp will be exponential and small factors can change individual months by an order of magnitude" speech? I've heard him say that at least 10 times, and yet investors keep asking the same dumb questions every earnings call.

Which isn't really that huge of a time sink, but then people go and make a big deal out of that stuff in the press, "Model 3 production was supposed to be 5,000 by year end, and it's looking more like 500... Tesla suffers 90% crash in production rate! It's all over folks!" Even though Musk described this scenario two years ago, and said it was accounted for in their planning.

Now imagine he's trying to get to Mars and every 3 months he has to go in front of investors who are asking, "So, your orbital launch rate for this quarter seems to be 50% lower than projections, would you say that's more due to your incompetence or is it more that your business model is fundamentally flawed?"

He's not optimizing for quarterly revenue. He's not optimizing for revenue at all, he's optimizing to make something fundamentally new and valuable happen, and he's calculating that the value will come, although it's never clear what year. But a segment of public investors seem unable to accept that story.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by deepGem on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @02:02AM (#15795065)
Unlike Tesla, Spacex is not a threat to any other publicly traded company AFAIK. So the barrage of negativity will be minimal. For every incompetent investor who comes on board, you'll have a great investor who'll trust you. This is the case in Tesla too. I mean, the odds that most of your investors will be incompetent is fairly low. It's not that much of a time sink, if you are running just one public company. Running two is a miracle. Jack Dorsey is doing it, so I wouldn't put it past Elon. All said and done, given a choice, Musk will keep Spacex private forever.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Ntrails on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @06:56AM (#15796400)
> For every incompetent investor who comes on board, you'll have a great investor who'll trust you.

Incompetence is blind trust. A good investor actually cares about the performance of the companies in which they invest - and that includes its ability to realistically project and meet those projections. A CEO who promises the moon on a stick and delivers little is not doing his job well. I am a fan of Elon, but you can't take a whole heap of money and then complain that people are interested.

As people have said, you can avoid this obligation to your shareholders by not having any.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by deepGem on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @07:43AM (#15806330)
A CEO who promises the moon on a stick and delivers little is not doing his job well

But Elon is not promising the moon. He is very clear when he states his goals, that these goals are very ambitious goals and that the probability of meeting them is fairly low.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:56AM (#15796078)
It must really sting; a company emits stocks back in the day for idk, $10 apiece and run with that, then for the rest of the company's existence they look at those same stocks and see them become worth $100, $1000, etc - the main people making money off of stocks are stock traders, not the company it was intended to fund.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Shivetya on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:54AM (#15796072)
well that and they don't have to have a 10 K report which can reveal more about the true state of a company that they wish to be public. in other words, you can go and stand before crowds all day and make glowing promises and reports but up against the SEC and investors you best damn have your ducks in a row.

there is a lot of additional reporting for publicly traded companies and that is a good thing.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by kinkrtyavimoodh on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:07PM (#15793382)
It's annoying enough that Tesla has to be public. I don't want to read the 1000th "Is it time to short SpaceX" comment here on elsewhere.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by anubisresources on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:26PM (#15793468)
That makes absolutely no sense. Buying TSLA is in no way a proxy for buying SpaceX equity.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by WalterBright on Wednesday November 29, 2017 @12:00AM (#15804686)
It makes sense if investing in the man rather than the company.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Tepix on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @04:43AM (#15795753)
I guess you will be able to invest into SpaceX via Gigafund eventually.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by jacquesm on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:24PM (#15793463)
I would happily buy SpaceX stock but I'd stay away from TSLA.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by dotancohen on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @01:28AM (#15794915)
> I would happily buy SpaceX stock but I'd stay away from TSLA.

And that right there is the reason that SpaceX will not be public. SpaceX is an investment in humanity, not a financial investment.

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by Cthulhu_ on Tuesday November 28, 2017 @05:57AM (#15796084)
That's a bit err, breathless optimism? SpaceX is a business that makes money off of sending shit to space, and it's optimizing for profit and/or lowering costs by reuse. The Mars philosophising is mainly for generating goodwill, they're not going to go there unless it makes them direct money or gives them PR credit.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by jerdfelt on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:43PM (#15793540)
You can get indirect exposure to SpaceX through some Fidelity mutual funds.

http://blog.sfgate.com/pender/2015/03/25/see-which-fidelity-...

Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by garmaine on Monday November 27, 2017 @08:57PM (#15793603)
0.04% of assets. That’s not even worth mentioning.
Re:SpaceX raises another $100M by njarboe on Monday November 27, 2017 @10:51PM (#15794207)
If the sf gate article is correct, Fidelity had a $84 million investment in SpaceX. This was part of a $1.0 billion round with Google that SpaceX says was just under 10%.[1] Looks like Google owns about 9% of SpaceX (I can't find this spelled out directly anywhere just goggling around).

If SpaceX is valued at about $20 billion, Google owns 9%, and Google's market cap is $720 billion, buying Google gets you 0.25% of that investment into SpaceX. Almost nothing, but better than Fidelity's exposure.

[1]http://www.spacex.com/news/2015/01/20/financing-round