I question the analogy. Seed funding might become a fad investment, but it will surely be less volatile than the subprime mortgage sector. Subprime mortgage originators and buyers backed their assets (the mortgages) by a large amount of debt. So, if their assumptions were only a small bit off (say defaults were 5.0% instead of 4.0%) the debt holders could demand a large amount of new collateral, more than the companies had on hand, forcing them into bankruptcy.
Most venture funds have little or no debt. If they overestimate their return by 25%, that means that they will earn 25% less than expected. They will not, however, go bankrupt.
You are also right that VCs and their investors are sensible as of now. It boggles the mind that highly leveraged companies would buy and hold on to high-risk bets.
Now I am highly skeptical that the same math extends to other seed companies. Do they get applicants of the same caliber when there are so many second tier seed companies to choose from for a prospective applicant? People are willing to uproot their youthful lives and move for YC, but will they do the same for Techstars or LaunchBox? Probably not, at least not for 15,000 dollars and little else. If I throw in the assumption of a power-law distribution for startups, the quality goes downhill rather rapidly. And additionally, if YC happens to be decently good at identifying truly promising candidates and taking them all into their fold as they claim to, it the median success probability for the rest is going to be rather low. Assuming an order of magnitude drop-off, that gives an payout probability of .09 ( 1-(1-1/1000)^100 if they are operating on same scales as used for YC). The number of seed companies sprouting is surely going to be limited by such math...