It seems to me that the categories of 'knowledge' and 'creativity' are more fruitful. For example, his idea that intelligence is 'situational' reflects the fact that people know more about some topics than others, and also that our environment contains knowledge (e.g. a machine embodies knowledge put there by the designers that the machine operator doesn't have).
Don't be absurd. Brains are simply biochemical computers. The idea of electrical or other types of computers superceding us is perfectly realizable. The only real debate is over the timeline.
On a separate note, does it even matter? Some people argue it's important so that we can put AI safe-guards in place, to protect mankind. But either:
A) Intelligence explosion won't happen and those safe-guards are not needed.
B) Intelligence explosion happens and the supersmart AI will easily find its way around feeble safe-guards put in place by the inferior humans.
While the end results are not the same; in either case the safe-guards are useless, though Asimov sure made a good story about them.
> but the issue here is that the author argues that there is no such thing as a general intelligence. It's all situational
An intelligence that can adapt to changing situations seems pretty general to me.
I like to think of AGI like the Warp Drive. It might well be possible, but we might never develop the capability to make one.
It actually is absurd and it's easy to see why: nature evolved a series of progressively more intelligent biochemical computers by accident, simply by trial and error.
If that's all we ever did with computers, like enumerating all Turing machines, we would eventually find one more intelligent than us. The fact that we can do even better than simple trial and error, for instance, by building machines that help us build machines, we drastically accelerate that inevitability.
Have you just proven that computers don't exist? I'm suffering a bit of cognitive dissonance here...
This isn't true at all.
http://slatestarcodex.com/2015/05/22/ai-researchers-on-ai-ri...
He argues that general intelligence by itself is not really something that exists, our brains exist within a broader system (environment, culture, bodies, etc.) which is something you can read more about in embodied cognition: https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/guest-blog/a-brief-guid...
He also argues that the public debate about "AI regulation" is misleading because it's impossible for a "seed AI" to start designing smarter AI's that will surpass the intelligence of humans which is what a lot of people today think will happen with AI. Automation of jobs and tasks is very real, but completely replacing humans and potentially destroying us all is a joke and only the people who no nothing about AI/brains think this.
[1] https://www.vanityfair.com/news/2017/03/elon-musk-billion-do...
[2] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/07/17/elon-musk-robots-will-be-abl...
[3] https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2017/07/17/537686649...