Re:Eric Schmidt on the Verizon Deal (et al)
by lutorm on Thursday August 05, 2010 @06:05PM
(#1579502)
As long as bandwidth is a scarce resource, something will happen. Either there's a well thought out procedure, or it's random. I think we can do better than random.
Re:Eric Schmidt on the Verizon Deal (et al)
by bjnortier_hn on Friday August 06, 2010 @04:43AM
(#1580562)
I argue that a "well thought out procedure" is not possible for such a complex system as the internet. Every kind of procedure that can be thought of will either have holes in the logic, or will be gamed by users and providers in a never-ending arms-race.
Emergent complexity is not "random", although it can be based on elements of randomness.
Nature is an example of a massively complex system that has evolved on elements of randomness, but the system itself is by no means random. And there's no way that it could have been designed with a "well thought out procedure".
I completely agree with roc that once you start thinking about it, there are just too many holes in the argument for prioritising on type. "Type" can just be a synonym for "provider". There will be nothing to prevent carriers to push new protocols to a non-priority "type", if they don't pay up.
If voip calls get priority, what prevents me from writing a torrent protocol over voip? That would just be a waste of bandwidth. Prioritising will set off a never-ending arms race.