News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by pyre on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @11:53PM (#1577143)

  >> They seem to be the first US company to happily surrender to the
  >> telecoms.
  > Google exists to make money. If surrendering to the telecoms makes
  > money then that's what they'll do.
That's a rather naive view of a complex question. Google has to balance short-, medium-, and long-term gains. If my only goal is to 'make money,' then I could make a ton of money if someone paid me $1-million to inject myself with the Ebola virus, but that's probably a fairly short-sighted decision...
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by rdtsc on Thursday August 05, 2010 @02:36AM (#1577391)
> That's a rather naive view of a complex question.

Absolutely correct. I thought someone would call me out on that so let me explain in more details:

It is still about making money. It is about the expected ability to keep making money in the future. I was talking about maximizing the global future returns function (you can think of it as the stock value). This function is some composition of the 3 functions you broke it down to.

That still doesn't change the goal.

However,as you argue, there is a set of decisions that when taken, might lead to maximizing short term profit at the expense of long term profit.

Google traditionally tried to maximize the long-term, by positioning itself on the positive side of the moral spectrum -- it is their well-known "do no evil" mission statement. This of course could just be pure PR. Or, if not, it could have resulted in taking some short term losses (not getting involved with repressive governments around the world, for example) while increasing long term gains (attracting the right kind of geeks who actually care about morals, human rights, freedoms, etc.).

[As a quick side node on such moral mission statements, one can argue that the losses taken as a result of defending a moral stance, might be a good measure of how serious and sincere that moral stance really is. I am not passing any judgement on Google one way or the other here, just pointing out a general guideline].

The bigger the company got, the more likely that short-term gains will be emphasized. The company has stopped being identified with the personae of the original founders. Consequently it's moral properties have been slowly pushed aside and it became just another faceless multi-billion dollar behemoth.

Don't get me wrong, I like Google. It is making me money. I bought stock in it. But, I never bought into its "morality" message. I just assumed it was a PR trick to attract the right talent. It worked great, you have to give it to them. Eventually they'll have to rely on PR again, when that bubble bursts to minimize the damage to it "good" public image. Perhaps, now is such a time...

Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by endlessvoid94 on Thursday August 05, 2010 @12:08AM (#1577180)
That's a bad analogy. Nobody would pay you to do that.
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by nkassis on Thursday August 05, 2010 @12:29AM (#1577220)
pharma corps without regulation? I might need to stop watching cyberpunk movies.
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by gwern on Thursday August 05, 2010 @03:31AM (#1577456)
Why would they bother? No money in ebola - rare, highly fatal, and seen only in the poorest places on earth.
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by Devilboy on Thursday August 05, 2010 @06:35AM (#1577693)
Bio-weapons division?
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by gwern on Thursday August 05, 2010 @07:03AM (#1577726)
Hardly any money in that, assuming it's even legal, and don't governments (quite sensibly) keep all that in-house anyway?
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by pyre on Thursday August 05, 2010 @03:51AM (#1577476)
How so? The point was to present an example of taking short-term gains that will have an effect on long-term gains. If Google blindly pursues only short-term gains, they risk weakening their medium- and/or long-term prospects.
Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by endlessvoid94 on Thursday August 05, 2010 @03:53AM (#1577477)
Because your short long term loss doesn't benefit anybody. The long term gain in google's case would be Verizon, but in your example, it's some evil corporation who just wants you to die.

That's unrealistic.

Re:Google and Verizon in Talks on Selling Internet Priority by jbooth on Thursday August 05, 2010 @11:16AM (#1578293)
whoooooooosh