Re:I'm on the FCC. Please stop us from killing net neutrality
by nerdponx on Thursday November 23, 2017 @05:25AM
(#15764156)
It's zero-sum
Not so fast. It's zero-sum if and only if call Internet subscribers have the same ability to pay for the service. If any user has a very high willingness to pay, but does not have the resources to pay it, then this amounts to a transfer of "wealth" (i.e. bandwidth) from that user to another who might not value it as much. It's not hard to construct utility curves in which this decreases total welfare.
That said, QoS is probably not the concern here. This is very much not a zero-sum proposal.
Not so fast. It's zero-sum if and only if call Internet subscribers have the same ability to pay for the service. If any user has a very high willingness to pay, but does not have the resources to pay it, then this amounts to a transfer of "wealth" (i.e. bandwidth) from that user to another who might not value it as much. It's not hard to construct utility curves in which this decreases total welfare.
That said, QoS is probably not the concern here. This is very much not a zero-sum proposal.