> Just like I don't want snail mail carriers opening my letters
Agreed
But you can pay for express delivery in which case your package is delivered over the other packages. Isn't that a good analogy of non-NN world?
Before you say 'I meant UPS charging one price to one manufacturer, and another to another', then UPS does that too. You can be very certain that UPS charges Amazon much lower shipping fee (due to the bulk business) than an independent seller on Amazon.
Vendors have been charging different fees to different businesses since forever, and we never had a problem mostly because nobody ever finds it more profitable to charge for printing Bible more than printing Sears catalog just because they don't like Bible.
You could spin this argument in the other direction and say that the contents in the pipe should be extremely visible and transparent to everybody. It would be a complete violation of privacy, but it will also identify (to everybody) the kinds of traffic flowing and the costs of that traffic in terms of congestion (if any).
Just like I don't want snail mail carriers opening my letters (even if it is strictly for the purpose of deciding whether or not they are important for speedy delivery).
There should be a protocol in which as much as possible is hidden. Even things like port numbers. From the traffic pattern it will usually be obvious whether it is bulk or interactive and such, and it has to be addressed, but beyond that, what protocol it is using, what port number and all that should be shrouded from prying eyes. If I have two connections going to the same host, it should not be possible for a wiretapper to tell which packets belong to which connection only "host A sent some blob to host B".