News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose th... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @02:52PM (#15750972)
> I'm not sure why people think the only that has held ISPs back from doing this is a 3yr old FTC regulation

The FCC has been enforcing neutrality principles since 2004, through case-by-case actions through 2010, and through regulatory orders in 2010 and 2015. Even in the brief window between case-by-case enforcement being struck down in 2010 and the 2010 Open Internet Order and the longer window between the 2010 Order being struck down and the 2015 Order, there was a clear regulatory direction which gave non-neutral activity a high-risk of being unsustainable and thus not worth investing in. There is very little competition in ISPs in most areas and very high barriers to entry; it isn't competition that has been controlling non-neutral behavior.

Re:FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose th... by dmix on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @03:34PM (#15751278)
Google or Amazon, or the rest of the tech industry, wouldn't be able to find the capital to build fast/unthrottled internet to eat Comcast's lunch? Alienating an entire industry and customer based like this would be a huge incentive for many parties, the market forces here are very much being downplayed.

Not to mention the technical hurdles (encryption, VPNs) outside of the risk involved of convincing an executive board to engage in a PR disaster and expose themselves to the risk of Google competing with them.

Besides has any company have tried to push TV-style packages, where they throttle websites depending on your package... and the FCC regulations stopped them? This is the scenario I keep reading about as what will happen if these regulations didn't exist. But I've yet to hear of an actual ISP trying this...

Typically with regulations you have the industry pushing back against them because they want to do certain things. But I'm not seeing that here, multiple ISP have already claimed they have no interest in engaging in this type of throttling and I personally don't see how this would ever fly even if they did.

Yes, cable companies have taken advantage of their political pull and monopoly positions to do some shady stuff but I'm very skeptical they could ever pull anything like that off in the internet. That's a whole different ball game than the tightly corporate controlled finite-content TV market and the tech industry and the public have clearly stated they won't sit idly by, regardless of regulations.

Re:FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose th... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @03:46PM (#15751368)
> Google or Amazon, or the rest of the tech industry, wouldn't be able to find the capital to build fast/unthrottled internet to eat Comcast's lunch?

Not while paying a Comcast (and other ISPs) tax to reach existing users, which then funds Comcast (et al.) staying ahead of them.

Re:FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose th... by dmix on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @03:54PM (#15751440)
That's a perfect example of the ridiculous lengths this idea would have to go to sound feasible. Hence why I believe it's so detached from reality.
Re:FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose th... by dragonwriter on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @03:59PM (#15751486)
ISPs have already selectively blocked particular firms (until agreeing to stop in response TO FCC enforcement action), so why (freed from the threat of enforcement) wouldn't they do that but also offer the firm a way to buy their way out of it?
Re:FCC plan would give Internet providers power to choose th... by dmix on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @04:06PM (#15751550)
You're changing the subject, that's not what you said above... you're taking a minor specific throttling and applying it to a large public company crippling the ISP competition of another large ISP company.

Yes, some monopolistic ISPs have engaged in specific minor throttling. What they haven't done is alienated their entire customer base by throttling the entire internet into packages. Which is an entirely different beast... and what we're talking about.