Re:Zed Shaw: "poll, epoll, science, and superpoll" with R
by adamtj on Wednesday August 04, 2010 @12:56PM
(#1574990)
I think he was suggesting that you find the ATR on real-world production webservers, which has nothing to do with your test and would not confound it. Maybe in practice nobody sees an ATR > 30%, in which case your test, if correct, is irrelevant. What sort of loads produce an ATR > 60%? How common are they?
One problem with getting such numbers is that real world, the load is given, not the ATR, and the ATR for a given load may depend on implementation choices. Total connections is a function of server latency, and on a loaded system, latency can be a function of polling method. So switching methods may change your ATR.
On the other hand maybe ATR for a given load doesn't change significantly depending on implementation. Your test found what is best for a given ATR, but not necessarily for a given load, or how ATR depends on load for a given implementation. Depending on the results, you may want to add some hysteresis to superpoll.
One problem with getting such numbers is that real world, the load is given, not the ATR, and the ATR for a given load may depend on implementation choices. Total connections is a function of server latency, and on a loaded system, latency can be a function of polling method. So switching methods may change your ATR.
On the other hand maybe ATR for a given load doesn't change significantly depending on implementation. Your test found what is best for a given ATR, but not necessarily for a given load, or how ATR depends on load for a given implementation. Depending on the results, you may want to add some hysteresis to superpoll.