I agree with you about consistency but 792ms is something though!
I remember when we upgraded from a 28.8k modem to ISDN. My Quake got a lot better purely because of lower latency. A friend was left behind on modem and he could tell the difference too, I was virtually unbeatable to him after the upgrade.
Of course we both knew that it was down to an unfair advantage so it wasn't a true victory.
I do recall playing World of Tanks with a 800ms Ping. After about 3 months or so I was back to thinking there was no Ping until a problem with my ISP was fixed and I dropped to 8ms. After which I ran into walls a lot.
The brain can adapt to such things rather well, given enough time.