News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Theories of civilisational ‘collapse’ grow less convincin... by Retric on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:42PM (#15742576)
Because this stuff is discoverable it's less important than you might think. When you have 10's of millions of archers doing that as a job then curving an arrow is not going to stay secret for that long.

The really major discoveries of our history are things like a positional number system aka zero. That's the kind of thing that's likely to survive because it's both really useful, easy to teach, and really common. Germ theory might not stick around, but it's really widespread and also both useful and the kind of thing we can pick up again.

The jump from an 8080 including an understanding of Quantum Mechanics getting to a modern multi billion transistor i7 is 100's of billions in research. But, going from an 8080's took us less than 100 years and we could do it again assuming a large relatively stable global economy.

Re:Theories of civilisational ‘collapse’ grow less convincin... by nkoren on Monday November 20, 2017 @05:18PM (#15743842)
Concrete is really useful. We lost it for 1,300 years. Calculus is really really useful. We figured out the basics, and then lost them for 2 millennia.[1] Flexible glass would be really useful. We apparently had it, then lost it, and never got it back.[2]

1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Archimedes_Palimpsest#The_Meth...

2: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flexible_glass

Re:Theories of civilisational ‘collapse’ grow less convincin... by Retric on Monday November 20, 2017 @07:50PM (#15744679)
Calculus was not lost as many original texts where preserved, however it was of limited use prior to Algebra being invited. Gothic cathedrals demonstrate a much more advanced practical matimatics than available to the Romeans. Who again could gather and transport resources over vast areas, but had a very low standard of living for the population on average.

Flexible glass was likely a tall tale instead of an actual thing with a several versions of the story existing, but no actual use of the substance.

Concrete was in continuous but limited use for the period your referring to. The limitation was transportation networks not knowledge.

Re:Theories of civilisational ‘collapse’ grow less convincin... by yourapostasy on Monday November 20, 2017 @03:34PM (#15742997)
I thought the same, until I looked back at when experiential knowledge was lost and then reacquired. If it is within a generation or two of loss and recovery, the process seems to proceed along the lines of what you mention. Beyond that, and recovery success rates looks like a cliff function. Metallurgy has been independently worked upon around the world, and specific aspects lost many times over. Someone demonstrated they were on the right path to working out precision hand-built gearing with the Antikythera mechanism. The discovered mechanism wasn't very accurate, but we lost that tech for about 13 centuries. Another way of considering that lost tech: it took about three centuries to get the first mechanical computers from the 14th century onwards (about when we recovered the level of the Antikythera mechanism's tech); we could potentially have had software on mechanical if not electronic computers say, 7 centuries ago, if the Antikythera tech was not lost.

Fast, bi-directional mass communications seems to be key to discoverability. Lose that, and all sorts of losses apparently accumulate quickly.

Of more immediate concern to me is the economic effects of classifying certain economic verticals as "low margin" and then deprecating them, as if some kind of central planning committee decreed that the industry shall forevermore never cross-pollinate or value-add any other industries. I'm not convinced it is that straightforward nor predictable. Somewhere in China at this moment, some college kid studying materials science has parents who work at a "low margin" garment factory, who through osmosis over the decades taught her about the ins and outs of industrial-scale, high-precision thread-manufacturing and tight weaving, and she's noodling about adapting that tech to manufacture say, glass foam insulation at 1/1000th the current cost, and revolutionize the global insulation industry forever.

It certainly is economically efficient in our local maxima to arrange our "developed-world's" industrial policy in this manner, but I think the jury is still out on whether or not it is sustainable; final arbitration will be history in a hundred years, but my bet is on China, who seems to have no qualms absorbing the industries "developed nations" no longer want, and doesn't seem as eager to divest as much or as fast to "lower tier" economies.

> ...and we could do it again assuming a large relatively stable global economy.

Here is where I have concerns "there be dragons". I've yet to read of many losses of industries (much less civilizational collapse) where there was sufficient stability to quickly recover; usually the recovery process, even when successful, was arduous and time-consuming. As rapidly as the global economy changes now, and with the global economy's new normal turbulence, I'm not convinced that recovery is any easier today than in earlier eras.

I am thankful for people who publish information like "From NAND to Tetris".

Re:Theories of civilisational ‘collapse’ grow less convincin... by Retric on Monday November 20, 2017 @05:19PM (#15743849)
Don't forget the role simple population size presents in terms of economic activity. Ancient Rome covered a huge territory, but a smaller population and GDP than Ethiopia does today.

Going from 1 billion to 7.5+ billion people world wide allowed for a huge increase in specialization and the sharing of knowledge. The benefit of building just one part of just one thing per day end up being huge.