News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber donates $1M to Meals on Wheels by chii on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:19PM (#15742368)
It's a paradox to me, since everyone i meet at any place seems really nice and want to make the world a better place. And yet, at some point, a company's mandate causes externalities that harm (usually for a profit motive). It's not a single individual that "did it" - it's more a collective force, like the tide.
Re:Uber donates $1M to Meals on Wheels by lhorie on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:40PM (#15742556)
I think there are two different aspects to this. The first is about what I'd call "active" vs "passive" caring (using the terms loosely, here). I'd say that passive caring is like when you, by principle, avoid looking for a job in the tobacco industry, or when your helping of people happens through your job. For example, I used to work in pharma marketing and you could say that it helped people find the right treatments or clinical trials for their conditions.

But then there's active caring: for example, when people spontaneously organize a volunteer drive. I admit that I'm more of a "passive caring" type of person myself, and I think the vast majority of people I've worked in the past fell in that category.

What I'm saying though, is that I literally hear people say they joined Uber _because_ they want to use the company's leverage to help people. This is something I'd never have heard in my previous jobs.

The second aspect is about sense of ownership. I feel that in previous companies, it was often easy to fall into a state of complacency because it wasn't clear if anyone higher up was listening to employees' concerns. At Uber, we have weekly all-hands meetings where literally _anyone_ in the company can ask Dara _any_ questions. We definitely had times earlier this year where people were a bit doubtful of the leadership team (especially around the first half of this year) and there were times people felt that positive changes were happening too slowly, but I think that overall there is a feeling that changes are indeed happening and that employees that want to make things better do have the power to make it happen.

Anyways. Not trying to toot Uber's horn. Just my personal opinion :)

Re:Uber donates $1M to Meals on Wheels by Fnoord on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:49PM (#15742644)
> What I'm saying though, is that I literally hear people say they joined Uber _because_ they want to use the company's leverage to help people. This is something I'd never have heard in my previous jobs.

Quite a common reason to go for a civil servant job which pays bad, such as police (at least in my country, YMMV).

> [...] or when your helping of people happens through your job [...]

Uber provides a service, just like the police dept., the hospital, the fire dept., Lyft, and Google search.

Its just that some of these also profile you.

It makes no difference whether Uber is owned by the US government as an official service, or whether it is a private company. Its still a service, regardless.

> At Uber, we have weekly all-hands meetings where literally _anyone_ in the company can ask Dara _any_ questions.

Which suggests this wasn't true with Travis.

Re:Uber donates $1M to Meals on Wheels by mkolodny on Monday November 20, 2017 @03:01PM (#15742738)
(disclaimer: I also work at Uber)

I think the paradox comes from seeing a company as a collective. Really Uber is a group of 15,000 individuals.

The company can only be successful if those individuals work together. But if one or two people do something bad, then people see it as Uber doing something bad.

As an engineer at Uber, I can only do so much to help make Uber better. But if I make one mistake I can bring down the app. It would be my mistake, but people would see it as Uber's fault.

There are processes and checks a company can put in place to prevent disasters (code reviews, tests, etc). But no matter what, individuals can and will make mistakes. I don't think it's fair for people to blame an entire company/culture for every mistake its individual employees make.

I think this is true of all companies (and societies/cultures). If one person does something wrong, it's that person's fault, not necessarily the fault of the entire company/culture.

Re:Uber donates $1M to Meals on Wheels by tmh79 on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:30PM (#15742464)
I'm also an uber employee, have been for a while. I totally understand the bad will against uber, but things inside the company have changed an insane amount since the january '17 stuff (deleteUber and fowler blog post), and with Travis out the new CEO Dara in, it feels like much... better company. Happy to talk more if there are specific questions.