News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Thomas Hobbes and Leviathan by anvandare on Monday November 20, 2017 @11:11AM (#15740942)
I read it more as OP meaning the social contract is not a suicide pact. Which is correct: a contract must be beneficial to both parties.
Re:On Thomas Hobbes and Leviathan by brudgers on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:23PM (#15741497)
Yes.

  *A Mans Covenant Not To Defend Himselfe, Is Voyd*

  A Covenant not to defend my selfe from force, by force, is alwayes voyd.
  For (as I have shewed before) no man can transferre, or lay down his
  Right to save himselfe from Death, Wounds, and Imprisonment, (the
  avoyding whereof is the onely End of laying down any Right,)
  and therefore the promise of not resisting force, in no Covenant
  transferreth any right; nor is obliging. For though a man may Covenant
  thus, "Unlesse I do so, or so, kill me;" he cannot Covenant thus "Unless
  I do so, or so, I will not resist you, when you come to kill me." For
  man by nature chooseth the lesser evill, which is danger of death in
  resisting; rather than the greater, which is certain and present death
  in not resisting. And this is granted to be true by all men, in
  that they lead Criminals to Execution, and Prison, with armed men,
  notwithstanding that such Criminals have consented to the Law, by which
  they are condemned.
https://www.gutenberg.org/cache/epub/3207/pg3207.txt
Re:On Thomas Hobbes and Leviathan by ubernostrum on Monday November 20, 2017 @11:59AM (#15741322)
a contract must be beneficial to both parties.

Except this isn't Hobbes' position. In his system, the benefit to the populace as a whole occurs only once: at the time the sovereign is invested with authority, ending the "war of all against all".

Once the sovereign has been given power, that's it. In Hobbes' system there are no further responsibilities on the sovereign's part to wield that power for a good purpose. There is no concept of power retained by the people, or power to overthrow the sovereign in the event the sovereign fails to provide what the people desire. In fact, such an idea is a contradiction in terms in Hobbes' system; there can be no power other than that which is possessed by the sovereign, because in Hobbes' system all power is ceded permanently and irrevocably to the sovereign.

Re:On Thomas Hobbes and Leviathan by brudgers on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:30PM (#15741561)
The ongoing benefit of the social contract is that the sovereign keeps the peace. If the sovereign fails to keep the peace, the sovereign is no longer sovereign (in the Hobbesian sense of 'sovereign'). As Dennis the Peasant says "Supreme executive power derives from a mandate from the masses." [1] That's why Leviathan's frontspiece [2] depicts the body sovereign as comprising many individuals rather than solid.

[1]: "not from some farcical aquatic ceremony."

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Leviathan_by_Thomas_Hobbe...

Re:On Thomas Hobbes and Leviathan by ubernostrum on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:34PM (#15742498)
Humor aside, Hobbes would not agree with you. He explicitly denies that the covenant can be breached by the sovereign, and explicitly denies that the people would have the right to remove or alter the government of the sovereign. Any principle of the sovereign "breaching" the covenant is non-Hobbesian, and probably a confusion with the theories of John Locke, which were radically different.