News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by ProAm on Sunday November 19, 2017 @11:11PM (#15737730)
Why does it need to be regulated? What ever happened to 'don't believe everything you read' and 'do your research'? No one has ever said Facebook holds anything remotely truthful, it's a social network. Your friends are not 100% honest or accurate. Same goes for Twitter, Reddit, Quora,...etc... It's always been a YMMV scenario, but for entertainment.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by rtkwe on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:25AM (#15738003)
What happened is that in a quest for more use and engagement sites and networks tuned their feed generation algorigthms to things that you’re more likely to like which isn’t stuff that goes against your world view/current conception of things. And there’s plenty of people out there more than happy to spin out tons of content for every niche so if you’re just looking and not critical of what sources you’re finding there’s a supporting source out there for every BS facebook/reddit/twitter post.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by Spivak on Monday November 20, 2017 @11:25AM (#15741049)
Right, but this same argument could be equally applied to any search engine or any popular 'content-neutral' platform.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by rtkwe on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:45PM (#15742611)
Facebook is in somewhat of a special position at this time because it is a really major source for a lot of people to get their news.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by stochastic_monk on Sunday November 19, 2017 @11:54PM (#15737884)
The problem is that people trust their friends on facebook. How do you protect the people who can't use critical thinking to get answers?

Using your reasoning, you might ask why it's bad to let vulnerable elderly individuals be hoodwinked out of their savings. What happened to their responsibility?

It seems to me that the people as a body are incapable of managing themselves and so they need safeguards. (Wow, that makes me sound like a dictator.)

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by dvt on Sunday November 19, 2017 @11:59PM (#15737904)
> Using your reasoning, you might ask why it's bad to let vulnerable elderly individuals be hoodwinked out of their savings. What happened to their responsibility?

It's a bit different because in your case, we're actively reducing harm. You can't just say "censorship will fix it" or "oversight will fix it" unless we're talking about specific scenarios. Which is why, in general censorship and oversight doesn't really fix anything.

This is also why laws are very detailed and specific. It would be nice to say "be good to one another" and be done with it.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by stochastic_monk on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:52AM (#15738076)
I agree. It would take a very specific set of interventions.

What could do good? A disclaimer every time you log in saying "Pro tip: get your news from reliable sources, not your facebook feed."? Are there any ways people could be prompted to do the right thing?

The question is then: what can be done? Just because it's hard to know how to handle the problem doesn't mean we shouldn't try to.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by ProAm on Monday November 20, 2017 @09:59AM (#15740279)
>The problem is that people trust their friends on facebook.

Do they? I don't, most of my friends are idiots (and still my best friends) Isn't that their fault however? The government cannot tell you to trust or distrust your friends.

> How do you protect the people who can't use critical thinking to get answers?

It's a scary world when you want the government to tell you what you are allowed to read and believe.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by stochastic_monk on Monday November 20, 2017 @11:43AM (#15741181)
1. You're not the problem. (And I wasn't either until I stopped using it years ago.) But many of the rest of people who use facebook are. And that's what makes manipulating them through faux grassroots methods so effective.

2. I didn't say I wanted the government to tell me or other people what they were allowed to read and believe. I'm saying I somehow want something to be done to help people realize that they can't trust everything they read online for unverified sources.

You're right that the government can't tell us whether to trust or distrust our friends. But can people be taught to think for themselves?

Maybe a better option is adding training to the curriculum specifically designed to teach students how to classify sources by bias and by probable authenticity.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by xena on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:08AM (#15737942)
That assumes people have the ability for critical thought, which is usually developed in school. Schools in the US have not been doing well due to lack of funding, so it makes sense that the populace at large is a bunch of idiots.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by whatyoucantsay on Monday November 20, 2017 @01:35AM (#15738229)
> Schools in the US have not been doing well due to lack of funding

Lack of funding isn't the cause.

Schools in the US receive more funding per pupil than schools in the EU or top performing Asian countries. More directly, the US spends more than Canada and gets far worse results. It's difficult to find the root of problem, but I would blame religiosity and widespread violent crime. Young earth creationists are still doing their best to hamstring the sciences no amount of money spent on a child can make up for a father who is dead or imprisoned.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by Splatter on Monday November 20, 2017 @02:18AM (#15738362)
Your reply started out good then sort of went off the rails. Care to cite supporting data that shows where "religiosity" and Young earth creationists are having a material impact on the overall US education system in the 21st century?
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by whatyoucantsay on Monday November 20, 2017 @04:03AM (#15738710)
As of 2014, well within the 21st century, 73% of Americans believe that God intervened in designing humans. 31% believe that evolution occurred but God guided the process, 42% of Americans believe that God created humans directly in their present form and only 19% believe that humans evolved without divine participation in the process.

http://news.gallup.com/poll/170822/believe-creationist-view-...

How could the educational system possibly be unaffected by most of the country still denying a foundational part of modern science?

Upon further investigation, we can see that it's not unaffected. Pitched battles are still being waged on intellectual ground settled generations ago in nearly every other developed country.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Creation_and_evolution_in_publ...

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by thousandautumns on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:30PM (#15741556)
You seem to be the one that is confused. A belief that human evolution occurred with no divine participation is not a foundational part of modern science. Neither 'God designing humans' nor 'God guiding evolution' are supported nor refuted by science because there is no evidence for or against either one. People like yourself often seem to misinterpret "there is no evidence for X" to mean "there is evidence that X does not exist" and that is not the case.

The reality is that only one of the above opinions, "God created humans directly in their present form" is provable/disprovable in any way and therefore the only one which science has anything to say about.

That said, 42% is still an admittedly high number. But you are the one who fails to understand a foundational part of modern science when you assume that correlation equals causation, and that increased religiosity results in poorer education while failing to realize that both are correlated with increased levels of poverty, which seems far more likely to cause poor education than religion.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by deadmetheny on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:10PM (#15741406)
Belief in God and being a Young Earth Creationist are not the same thing, not at all. I know this may be hard for the oh-so-enlightened atheist tech crowd to believe, but many people can hold religious convictions and also have intelligent and scientific minds.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by wccrawford on Monday November 20, 2017 @10:53AM (#15740755)
And Europe and Asia aren't similarly affected?
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by Spivak on Monday November 20, 2017 @11:31AM (#15741095)
It's nice to know that HN is still as condescending as ever. Making an argument that relies on the premise that everyone else is stupid says less about people and more about how you think of others.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by intended on Monday November 20, 2017 @01:59AM (#15738298)
Yeah its always been the YMMV scenario - even when it was only the old coders on the web.

With everyone on the web, it turns out that now large meta processes - like elections, are being affected.

At this point, things are no longer the same, and new meta systems are required.

The world changed, and the internet is no longer just for us.

Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by s0rce on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:05AM (#15737929)
Looks like people aren't smart enough to do this on their own (sadly). Either they need education (difficult, expensive and some people don't want to be "educated") or just regulate what they see and read.
Re:We Can’t Trust Facebook to Regulate Itself by ProAm on Monday November 20, 2017 @09:56AM (#15740249)
It's a scary world when you want the government to tell you what you are allowed to read and believe.