The only way to learn something (and certainly programming) at a high level is to force yourself to write down a well- defined, closed-end problem, and then sit down and solve the motherf_____r. You learn what you need to learn, build, and invent along the way, and that survives longer than the original problem.
This is how I've been successful as a self-taught developer.
However, I didn't become amazingly successful in life.
Note that I do not think this applies to books that simply showcase and act as a more advanced reference of programming languages. Those are normally plain enough, I think.
For others subjects, like math or CS, multiple sources have always proven invaluable for me.
I still second your system. Makes me wanna try.
Learning a music instrument right now, and a combination of youtube, guitar instruction books, and earing music off my music player seems to be the strategy that makes the most gains. That and spaced repetition (5 1-hour practices sessions is better than 1 5-hour practice session)
I get at least two, preferably three data sources on the same subject. Read them all in Parallel and take notes. Getting multiple perspectives is critical.
What works for me is two well-made textbooks and a Youtube series, iTunes university, etc course.
““In almost all textbooks, even the best, this principle is presented so that it is impossible to understand.” (K. Jacobi, Lectures on Dynamics, 1842-1843). I have not chosen to break with tradition.”
–V. I. Arnold, Mathematical Methods of Classical Mechanics [5], footnote, p. 246