News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How do you read programming books? by BeetleB on Sunday November 19, 2017 @12:32PM (#15734829)
>Similar to cartoons, I have similar complaints about "conversational style" that many authors think helps with pedagogy but it really doesn't. (You can explain things terribly while using a conversational tone, and likewise, explain things clearly without a serious tone.) I'll save that criticism of that for another essay.

If "you can explain things terribly while using a conversational tone, and likewise, explain things clearly without a serious tone", then does it not suggest the tone is not a good signal for quality?

David Griffith's Intro to EM book is written in conversational style. And is by far the best book I've seen on introductory EM (and I've read a bunch).

Re:Ask HN: How do you read programming books? by jasode on Sunday November 19, 2017 @12:39PM (#15734886)
>, then does it not suggest the tone is not a good signal for quality?

You highlighted my spelling mistake and I updated the post to correct it. My examples were meant to be opposites.

There are many bad books out there with a conversational style. There are good ones too. The problem is that readers are mislead by the easy-going tone of the first few pages and therefore lulled into thinking it's a quality book because of its chattiness and informality.

Likewise, many authors writing in a conversational style think they wrote an easy-to-understand book because it's conversational. That cause & effect isn't true. One can write a beginner book that has clear teaching with or without a conversational style.