Tim Pool recounted how his account got verified a few days ago: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=67nFNUPQaeI&t=1m25s.
TL;DW: His employer, VICE, instructed Twitter to verify him, and they did.
Ultimately that's what this badge comes down to: for most people it's a mark of being on the inside, knowing the right people. The right agency, the right employer, maybe just having a friend working at Twitter. There are some other certain criteria that aren't publicized, and they have in the past randomly given it out to "high profile" people on Twitter, even though that seems to be totally random as well.
This is a special club, Twitter has on and off said it means many things, but there's no consistency. Just like there's no consistency with how they enforce their rules, there's no consistency with this special privilege either.
Twitter gives the status to people who have good connections to Twitter.
Given we all agree on this being the actual state of things, getting mad at them for giving this status to white nationalists makes complete sense. Twitter is boosting these people with this verification process that serves to boost their friends.
If we think that the blue checkmark makes you belong to the country club, who you let in is a signifier of Twitter's beliefs.
https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/twitter-announces-a...
>We hope opening up this application process results in more people finding great, high-quality accounts to follow
This seems to be where the line started blurring between "this is who they say they are" and "this account is an asset to our platform."
I was under the same impression that OP was, so I looked up the verified account announcement from the Twitter in 2009[1]:
"To prevent identity confusion, Twitter is experimenting (beta testing) with a 'Verified Account' feature. We're working to establish authenticity with people who deal with impersonation or identity confusion on a regular basis."
[1] https://web.archive.org/web/20090615114316/http://twitter.co...