News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by cgore on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:12PM (#15724436)
I'm a white guy. I'm a software engineer. I'm totally cool with hiring people who aren't white guys (assuming they can do the job.) It seems that Denise Young Smith understands that, but there's a weird fringe of the extreme left that only sees headcounts by color and gender, and only sees me as "a white guy", and only sees others as "an <enthnicity> <gender>", and it's sad that a black woman got fired for being reasonable instead of having a specific and idiotic political agenda.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by jasode on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:39PM (#15724727)
To use the fired Apple employees idea that diversity is multidimensional, you might have the following situations:

Group 1:

  1) white man (Democrat Stanford grad)
  2) white woman (Democrat Stanford grad)
  3) black man (Democrat Stanford grad)
Group 2:

  1) white man (Democrat Stanford grad)
  2) white man (Libertarian Kansas kid self-taught)
  3) white man (South Africa bootcamp grad)
Depending on what's important, Group 2 would be seen as "more diverse and representative" even though the skin color is all the same. In that case, diversity of thought is valued more than diversity of skin color.

If that was the idea that Denise Young Smith was trying to get across, that nuance got lost in the backlash.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by dilap on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:53PM (#15724866)
nah, it wasn’t missing nuance — this idea, as you expressed it, is considered unacceptable by many people right now.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by omegaworks on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:50PM (#15724825)
* Why assume Group 2 has, or can produce, higher-valued thoughts?

* Why are there only three seats at the table?

Diversity and inclusion is about analyzing and addressing systemic assumptions and the arbitrary, exclusionary constraints we put on ourselves as an industry.

Contrived hypothetical scenarios fail to frame the real problem because those contrived scenarios are exactly what good policies push back against.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by dictum on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:03PM (#15724969)
I don't see where the parent comment implies Group 2 is expected to produce "higher-valued" thoughts.

Neither more diversity of thought between members of a group OR a single leaning, shared by all members of a group imply higher value.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by omegaworks on Sunday November 19, 2017 @03:47PM (#15735851)
The parent comment doesn't just imply that Group 2 has more valuable thought-diversity, they state it out right:

> In [Group 2's] case, diversity of thought is valued more than diversity of skin color.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by zaarn on Monday November 20, 2017 @05:11AM (#15738921)
No, that simply states that the diversity property of the thought is higher, not that the value property of the thought is higher.

And you claimed, quote, "Why assume Group 2 has, or can produce, higher-valued thoughts?"

Value of Thought and Diversity of Thought are two independent properties that can coexist independently.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by omegaworks on Monday November 20, 2017 @12:01PM (#15741339)
>Value of Thought and Diversity of Thought are two independent properties that can coexist independently.

Sure. But that's not what parent is claiming. Parent is claiming that the company that prefers to hire Group 1, values diversity of thought over diversity of skin color.

The assumption there is that Group 2 can't offer that same "diversity of thought." Parent doesn't consider whether "diversity of thought" actually follows from how parent defines Group 1, or that valuing "diversity of thought" in the way that it's claimed will make the company better.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by zaarn on Tuesday November 21, 2017 @02:48AM (#15746369)
There is no assumption since in this thought experiment the two groups have been defined to be how they are as an example which does not necessarily reflect reality 100%.

This means diversity of thought necessarily follows form the example given as it was defined as such (group 1 has diversity of thought, group 2 not).

The importance of diversity of thought can be illustrated by using machine learning; if your learning factor (diversity of thought) is too low, not all solutions are explored, instead a local minima is found and then reinforced by the ML algorithm. If the learning factor is higher then the algorithm can freely explore for other local minima and maybe even find the absolute minima. (If it's too high then you also don't get anything useful either but that's not quite the point)

Diversity of thought is important for a company that wants to make better product, if you only have people who think alike, regardless of their other properties, they will not find the best optimal solution, only a local optimal solution.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by LordKano on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:13PM (#15725062)
I'm a black guy in tech. I have never had a problem in the industry solely because of my race. I have had personality conflicts that may have been exacerbated because of culture differences but it was the personality conflicts that were the root.

Now, even I am being painted as "Not diverse enough" for the contingent of which you speak. Recently, I read this and it sums up where it's all heading next.

https://verysmartbrothas.theroot.com/straight-black-men-are-...

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by rocmcd on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:40PM (#15725326)
Thanks for the link. That was an eye-opening read.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by bertomartin on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:36PM (#15725295)
I guess we all have different experiences
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by dmschulman on Friday November 17, 2017 @03:46PM (#15725823)
apt point
[dead]
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by sctb on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:53PM (#15724870)
You can keep your moniker, but we ban accounts that use Hacker News primarily for ideological and political battle—regardless of which ideology. Please change this now.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by whichdan on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:39PM (#15724724)
"people who aren't white guys (assuming they can do the job.)"

This sort of language is problematic and harmful in that it implies that "white guys" (not even white people, just men) by default can always "do the job," and that anyone outside of that group must be judged to some sort of different standard. It makes it challenging to talk about diversity when statements start off with racist and sexist undertones.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by fosk on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:45PM (#15724783)
Oh come on, you know what he meant.

This is getting to a point that even genuinely talking about it, and rightly so, risks backfiring at you because there’s always somebody willing to make 10 extra mental steps to find it offensive.

Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by ksk on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:20PM (#15725134)
Its really frustrating that peoples innocent statements are purposely twisted like this to suit personal agendas.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by whichdan on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:50PM (#15724821)
They could have easily omitted the "assuming they can do the job" part without affecting the statement. There's a reason that it was added.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by tga on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:59PM (#15724935)
Exactly, and the reason is the implied risk of unchecked "diversity" leading to hiring underqualified people just for the sake of boosting quotas.
Re:Apple’s diversity chief out after outcry by ksk on Friday November 17, 2017 @02:25PM (#15725175)
Your statements are needlessly accusatory, and increase rather than decrease friction. You could have said something like "Hey, I know you probably didn't mean it this way, but some people might read this into your statement. Do you see that too? What do you think?"