Re:The Paradise Papers: How Ridiculously Easy It Is for the ...
by rayiner on Friday November 17, 2017 @12:35PM
(#15724044)
Where do you draw the line between legitimate avoidance and illegitimate avoidance? My wife and I bought a house in order to lower our tax bill. I think it's wrong to have a huge tax deduction primarily benefiting people who already are well off. But is that illegitimate avoidance? What about estate planning, which encourages individuals to divest assets to their kids on a certain schedule so as to maximize how much of their nursing home care is paid for by Medicare/Medicaid instead of their own assets. Is that illegitimate avoidance? How about deferring capital gains tax on the sale of equities by instead taking a loan using the equities as collateral. What differentiates these things?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Paradise Papers: How Ridiculously Easy It Is for the ...
by roel_v on Friday November 17, 2017 @12:47PM
(#15724157)
Well it's obvious - when it's done by someone in my income class and I expect to do it at some point in the future, it's fine and I'm already paying enough in taxes; but when it's done by someone who has more money than I do, they're thieving capitalists who should be thrown in jail.
Re:The Paradise Papers: How Ridiculously Easy It Is for the ...
by charlesdm on Friday November 17, 2017 @01:08PM
(#15724395)
You can't draw a line, which is part of the problem. In addition, the moral compass of various people can and will be different. What I think is fine, someone else will think is excessive.
As long as there are smart people, you will have avoidance. The capital gains deferral is a simple example of something that is hard to fix. And there are a ton of situations like that.
If this was an easy problem to solve, it would have been solved. In fact, I'd go as far as saying that it can't actually be solved. You can get rid of tax havens, but tax avoidance has existed for 2000+ years. In fact, in most cases, you don't even need to go "offshore" to secure great tax benefits.
There used to be a window tax: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Window_tax. Guess what? People avoided it by bricking up their windows.
Re:The Paradise Papers: How Ridiculously Easy It Is for the ...
by harryh on Friday November 17, 2017 @04:52PM
(#15726297)
Why does the cap gains deferral need to be fixed? The gov't will get its money one day. Who cares if exactly when gets moved around a few years one way or the other?