News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC plans to vote to overturn U.S. net neutrality rules i... by shkkmo on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:37PM (#15717338)
I hold the highly unusual view that voting to elect representatives is a inefficient and ineffective way of accurately determining the will of the people.

Our current system predominantly favors white, rich, cis-gendered male christians who are good at manipulating their constituents and getting rich people and corporations to give them money. This seems like such an awful set of criteria that it is hard to see how just picking randomly could fail to be better. (There is evidence that sometimes it is better to choose randomly than relying on ineffective criteria: https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2014/oct/10/random-...)

Even if you eliminate the problems of campaign finance and winner-takes-all in elections we are still left with the distorting incentives of re-election (though enforced single terms could help with that.)

State representatives that want to be successfully re-elected, need to bring home the pork and this incentives wasteful government spending. They also need to avoid taking political stances that might cost them the election, even when it has popular support and would be beneficial to our society (e.g. gun laws, criminal reform and the legalization of marijuana).

Removing perverse incentives of re-election and moving to random selection for one of our chambers of representatives would mean less pointless pork barrel spending, reduce the incentives for corruption, and lead to a more representative demographic sampling with a better personal understanding of the economic and social challenges we face as a society.

Re:FCC plans to vote to overturn U.S. net neutrality rules i... by flavor8 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:44PM (#15718098)
Interesting. I'm not sure that random selection would be effective though - just look at the jury system, where the opinion of the relatively domain-uninformed body is manipulated by domain experts to attempt to reach the outcome that they desire. The same sort of thing would happen (IMO) in a political body -- the "shadow" government (i.e. the career government workers) would end up manipulating members of the body to a greater or lesser extent.
Re:FCC plans to vote to overturn U.S. net neutrality rules i... by shkkmo on Thursday November 16, 2017 @11:34PM (#15718948)
> the "shadow" government (i.e. the career government workers) would end up manipulating members of the body to a greater or lesser extent.

Certainly a risk, but we have already have a similar shadow government of congressional aids and special interest lobbyists today. I think this can be mitigated to some degree by providing funding and resources for self education, but this is something that would need to be taken under consideration as the system was designed and measured as the system was implemented.