News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:31PM (#15716828)
The headline is sensationalist click-bait, but it is the title of the article, and the article is an opinion piece. I'm not sure whether the HN entry should be re-named or not.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:36PM (#15716874)
I don't know if calling it sensationalist is reasonable.

>This means that M.I.T. graduate students would be responsible for paying taxes on a $80,000 annual salary, when we actually earn $33,000 a year. That’s an increase of our tax burden by at least $10,000 annually.

Getting by on $28,000/year (taking into consideration 15% in taxes) is really tough. Getting by on $18,000/year is almost impossible. And if they're working 40-80 hour weeks then they hardly have time to do anything else.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:02PM (#15717512)
OK, but by that standard, undergrads are already bankrupt, because they're paying $45,000 per year on a salary of $0. So, yes, I think it's still fair to call it sensationalist.

What's actually going to happen is that universities are going to have to pay their grad students more - which they will, because grad students are still a cheap resource for the university.

At least, that's what would happen in a reasonable situation. Education often isn't, though.

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:08PM (#15717547)
>OK, but by that standard, undergrads are already bankrupt, because they're paying $45,000 per year on a salary of $0. So, yes, I think it's still fair to call it sensationalist.

Well, they probably have scholarships.

>What's actually going to happen is that universities are going to have to pay their grad students more - which they will, because grad students are still a cheap resource for the university.

Well, they won't be cheap if they have to pay them more!

>At least, that's what would happen in a reasonable situation. Education often isn't, though.

And it's somehow reasonable to tax discounts like income?

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by AnimalMuppet on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:34PM (#15718038)
> Well, they probably have scholarships.

Some do. More have loans.

> Well, they won't be cheap if they have to pay them more!

Compared to professors? They'll still be cheap - just not as cheap as before.

> And it's somehow reasonable to tax discounts like income?

Maybe? If I work for a car dealership, and they give me a car as part of my employment there, it seems reasonable to me that the car counts as part of my compensation, and therefore is taxable. If they sell me the car for $1 because I'm employed there, it seems reasonable to me that that "discount" is part of my compensation, and is therefore taxable. On the other hand, if I work anywhere, and my company pays for my health insurance, that is not taxable, and nobody wants it to be.

So which is the "normal" case, the car or the health insurance?

Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by benjohnson on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:41PM (#15716922)
Solution: don't work for free.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:46PM (#15716963)
They weren't, though.
Re:The House Just Voted to Bankrupt Graduate Students by cperciva on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:33PM (#15716843)
Maybe it needs '[Opinion]' added to make the context clear?