News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by lostapathy on Thursday November 16, 2017 @12:53PM (#15714791)
Property taxes are fairly progressive, from where I sit. Richer people have more assets and would pay more taxes.
Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by ams6110 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @01:51PM (#15715363)
Except there is no accounting for income. So if I'm poor, or become poor, I still have to pay the assesed property tax on any property I own. I may be forced to sell the property as a result.

Property tax works against poor people being able to own property or keep property they own.

This is why elderly people who may own their homes free and clear can still be forced out of them when they retire or become disabled.

Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by function_seven on Thursday November 16, 2017 @03:41PM (#15716407)
A fix to this would be to lien the property with the unpaid taxes, but not force the sale. Eventually, the owner will sell or die. The tax liens can be recovered at that point.

For an example tax of 2%, the property could sustain the liens for decades, allowing the owner to keep control of the land, even if they're unable to pay the taxes owed. The revenue to the government could be provided by bonds backed by those liens. Maybe require some portion of the tax to be paid in cash, and some penalty rate on the liens, to encourage payment of taxes by those that can afford them?

Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by tmnvix on Thursday November 16, 2017 @02:55PM (#15715982)
> ...if I'm poor, or become poor, I still have to pay the assesed property tax on any property I own.

Are you really poor if you own valuable assets?

Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by wils1245 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @03:14PM (#15716176)
Speaks to a problem of means testing property taxes on anything other than the property value - how to define poor in a way that can’t be games by skillful accounting?
Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by krrrh on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:44PM (#15717739)
Many jurisdictions offer deferred property tax payments for the retired, or disabled.

Aside from that, someone who owns valuable fixed property free and clear should be able to find a lender who can open a small mortgage against the property to cover taxes.

Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by s73ver_ on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:55PM (#15717813)
I would still require income to be able to pay back that mortgage.
Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by hx87 on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:57PM (#15717061)
If you're poor, how did you come to own the assets in the first place?

If you became poor, then maybe you should sell the property to gain more liquidity, balance your portfolio, and transfer the property to someone with enough income to fully maintain it.

Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by s73ver_ on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:58PM (#15717826)
People's situations change all the time. And saying that someone should have to leave their property that they own because they can't afford the taxes on it is pretty awful. Especially if they can't afford them because property values spiked.
Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by s73ver_ on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:55PM (#15717808)
They can also be quite regressive. If you buy a house somewhere, live in it and retire, and then property values shoot up, you're kinda screwed.
Re:Amazon Sellers Brood as States Come Calling for Taxes by ghaff on Thursday November 16, 2017 @11:29PM (#15718934)
Hence Prop 13 in California--which lots of folks here complain about on a regular basis.