As a smaller ISP we are constantly asked for cheaper plans for - typically - older people who "just want to check their email." Thanks to net neutrality we cannot offer these people anything.
We are forced to compete DIRECTLY against the comcast's and AT&T's in our region. A competition where our only weapon is cost. And if we lower our costs we only get a bunch of power users who consume 10x more bandwidth than typical users - the big business marketing departments eat our budgets for breakfast.
Without net neutrality the first thing we'd do is setup a "email only" plan - charge $5 a month and literally knock on doors in retirement homes and sign up swaths of people. We could probably oversell the single line by an order of magnitude more than usual.
Net neutrality directly prevents any sort of choice for the consumer as to what level of internet access they want or need. And yes that might sound scary - but the VAST majority of people in certain age groups just simply dont WANT to pay $80 a month to check their email.
Eliminating NN will make competition even worse for smaller and medium sized ISPs because the big ISPs have disproportional leverage to extract subsidies from media companies and make all sorts of deals. In some cases, the ISPs even own the media companies (for example, Comcast owns NBC). How can you possibly expect to compete with that?
Under current net neutrality rules, is it possible to sell a data capped plan (but content agnostic), with overages, where the data capped portion is below rival “uncapped” plans?
That way it seems like one could attract that demographic without the downside you highlighted.
As for caps - which do you think would sell people better: "You have full access to anything on your email" vs "You can download 500 mb of data a month"
And what will happen to their service when the grand kids come over and want to watch netflix?
A low-speed broadband plan (or even dialup) would serve those customers fine, no?
> As for caps - which do you think would sell people better: "You have full access to anything on your email" vs "You can download 500 mb of data a month"
What if those emails link to some other site on the internet? Or contain photo or video links? Does it still count as “full access” if things slow to a crawl in those cases? With email being so small anyway, how does that differ in practice from just a low speed plan? It could still be marketed as “access to everything in your email.”
> And what will happen to their service when the grand kids come over and want to watch netflix?
This question itself seems to undermine your point. What would happen in that situation, on a plan like the one you’d like to sell?
Otherwise, without NN, we have to rely on ISPs "word" they won't just start forcing cable packages on us. No fucking thanks.
Comcast's of the world can oversell their lines by 4x what we can because they can simply get the word out to low-traffic users better than we can. Thats 4x the revenue smaller ISPs just don't get directly because of NN.
Being able to do so is great for the company in charge of the utility, but literally everybody else immediately loses hard.
There's nothing stopping them from doing this now, but the fact of the matter is ISPs don't want competition.
> Comcast's of the world can oversell their lines by 4x what we can because they can simply get the word out to low-traffic users better than we can.
So NN prevents you from getting the word out? Huh?
That is an utter baldfaced lie. NN is not what is keeping competition down, not even close.
If you want sympathy and understanding for your position, it helps if you be honest with the rest of us.
Telling a customer they have full access to anything on their email vs telling a customer they have 500mb a month. Which do you think sells better?
They think that they only want email, but what they really want is to access the internet via their email.
And of course monitor account usage and call up tech-savvy granddads who email themselves youtube videos to get around the block.
Also, I don't think I've ever heard such a misuse of the word "simply"
What? What constitutes a "link"? This doesn't make any sense.
4 links away from gmail - not allowed. Pretty simple
Sorry, not interested in giving it up so you can bilk and spy on the elderly.
I guess people actually would need to be able to still install software updates etc, which might be tricky if strictly capped?
2. If you are not providing last mile, you are not competing with comcast, verizon, at&t or whoever else owns that infra.
I care far, far, far more about net neutrality, and not having the internet get fucked, than about your company making money.
In theory you'd think we could make motorized land vehicles with all random power outputs just like boats, but in practice they're all within an order of magnitude, how odd.
From an engineering standpoint I'm not sure what we could take away from a modern car to make a "Sunday church only" car that would still be street legal and not result in immense staggering levels of customer dissatisfaction. In addition, I'm kinda claiming old people saying all they want is email, are lying. The instant you sell that "email only" product the instant the phone lines light up with support calls. They don't actually want it, they want cheaper prices and they're hoping that stereotype will sell their request. They have no idea that "email only" would be costlier to provide, they just think its an inferior position so gimmie a lower bill. In summary, we can't sell it because it would be a support nightmare and its maybe not possible to engineer without significant extra expense.
The thing about market segmentation is that its very expensive to implement legacy long distance telco style era billing infrastructure... we aren't gonna split product prices from current price X into X/2, X/3, X/4 for inferior products. To fund the billing infrastructure we're going to split into 2(X+100), 0.75(X+100) etc. Both a VERY high offset to fund the billing costs, and an additional medical insurance style monopoly increase to multiples of higher price, not lower. Killing net neutrality is about monopoly middlemen raising prices, never about lowering them.
An even closer although more stretched analogy is a modern car that can drive across the country at high speeds is going to cost almost exactly as much as a car that can just barely drive to the post office. Its not like turn signals or air bags are any cheaper. Certainly there's no such thing as single mode fiber optic lasers that are only rated for email checking vs 10G multiplayer gaming use.
I've noticed watching my kids that bandwidth use has stopped increasing. Thru my life bandwidth use only increased, over many orders of magnitude. That era is over, and we're raising kids who have constant BW use over the course of their lives. For context my daughter is the same age as Youtube and nothing has happened since then WRT BW use. Everything other than streaming video is a rounding error and trillions of hours watched show resolution and quality are totally optional for video consumption despite decades of broadcast engineers and professional producers claiming the contrary in the legacy media.
Something as easy as allowing email + 3-4 links past email would solve virtually all problems and support calls and a bit of usage monitoring would eliminate the fraud
Ask people if they like being more-or-less forced to use some companies over others, or if they like paying a premium for online gaming. Ask people how they'd feel if Optimum decided to slow down traffic to Fox News if Fox News released a story unfavorable to Optimum. Ask people how they'd feel if a startup that intended to compete with Netflix was effectively shut out of the market by deals like theirs with TMobile.
Better yet, show them an image of internet packages ala cable. That'll make them change their tune.
Free up the protectionism we're granting to major telcos and let the consumer choose what they are willing to pay for.
Edit: Ultimately the consumer must own the "last mile" that is feeding their residence. In that way, ISPs would lease space in the residential IDF to tie willing customers in that neighborhood in.
You're gonna have to do a much, much better job of explaining why zero rating is a good thing.
Tell people they can get zero rating on their favourite services, and the result of such a referendum will be uncomfortable for many.
I'm really tired of seeing people everywhere thinking net neutrality is "unquestionable", "universally good" and "the will of the people". Ever bothered to ask anyone outside the tech circles? Or you simply think you know what's best for everybody?