News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by eesmith on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:13AM (#15711251)
How much time do you think is needed?

In the "Sample grade 10 Gymnasium timetable", there's as much time spend on "religious studies" as "biology" (2 periods per week). In the "Sample grade 12 Gymnasium timetable", it's also 2 periods per week, and equal to the time spent on "Politics-Economy".

This seems well more than needed in order to understand the history.

Is the high school-level religious education in Germany really taught as a comparative religion that includes the world's religions?

The discussion at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religious_education#Germany says that most of the German states teach "religious (Christian) education in close cooperation with the churches", and the teachers are "paid by the state and are bound to the German constitution, as well as answerable to the churches for the content of their teaching."

The discussion at https://www.german-way.com/history-and-culture/germany/relig... :

"A standard part of the public school curriculum in Germany is religious instruction (Religionsunterricht). For the most part, this is confined to Catholic or Protestant students, but some states also offer instruction for Jewish students. In Berlin three public schools also offer instruction for Buddhists. Although religious instruction is a required subject (according to the German Constitution!), students above a certain age (or by parental request) can opt out for personal reasons.

"Only in recent years has there been any discussion of offering Islamic instruction for students belonging to Germany’s largest non-Christian religious minority, but no German state (Bundesland) currently offers instruction for Muslim students in German, in the same way that Christian instruction is offered. ... What about the various forms of the Muslim religion (Sunni, Shiite, Alevite, etc.) and ethnic divisions (Turk, Albanian, Pakistani, etc.)?"

This makes it sound like the German courses teach the tenets of a specific faith, and are not a comparative/world religion training.

Lastly, understanding religious is important to an understanding of history. Does the German religious history really cover some of the negative sides of religion like the (early) Christian justification for slavery (eg, the Romanus Pontifex, Dum Diversas, and Inter Caetera)?

Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by emodendroket on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:17AM (#15712083)
I make no warrants about what they teach in Germany because I'm not German, nor particularly well versed on the topic.
Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by eesmith on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:45AM (#15712204)
You were responding to my statement "While I look at the sample schedules at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Education_in_Germany#Timetable.... and wonder about all the time wasted in religious studies" so I thought you were still on the topic of education in Germany.

Even if we shift topics, my first question still stands - how much time do you think should be spent on comparative religion classes at the high school level in the US?

As a follow-up, which course should it replace?

Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by emodendroket on Thursday November 16, 2017 @09:15AM (#15712712)
The question doesn't make a lot of sense since there is no standardized curriculum, nor am I saying that we necessarily need to have religious education for the entirety of schooling (although I think more than we get would be reasonable considering the importance of questions like iconoclasm to early settlers). The sentiment I was responding to was specifically that time spent learning the subject is wasted. Time doesn't have to be spent in a 100% optimal way, however we measure that, to not be wasted.
Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by eesmith on Thursday November 16, 2017 @02:31PM (#15715739)
Everything I said is in regards to the top-level comment by jfaucett at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15706042 . I used the term "wasted" because that jfaucett wrote that "the system here in Germany ... doesnt waste your time as much" as the US.

You changed to a different topic. I did not argue "that time spent learning [comparative religious studies] is wasted", yet you bring it up again.

Since there is no required religion courses in public schools in the US (that I know of), I of course agree that there is no standardized curriculum.

It appears that most federal states in Germany has religious education for the entirety of schooling. It also appear that you may think that is excessive, compared to your preferences.

Does this mean that we agree?

Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by emodendroket on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:15PM (#15716698)
> Since there is no required religion courses in public schools in the US (that I know of), I of course agree that there is no standardized curriculum.

Not what I mean. There is no federal, standardized curriculum at all in the US (although all the standardized tests with competencies, Common Core, etc. are strides in this direction), so asking me what course I think should be put aside doesn't make a lot of sense, since there isn't one set of courses to think about in the first place. But, sure, while it makes sense for religious schools (e.g., Catholic private schools), I don't think public schools need to be making religious studies a core subject on par with science, math, English, etc.

Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by eesmith on Thursday November 16, 2017 @04:37PM (#15716891)
I know that there is no federal curriculum in the US. Then again, I wasn't being that restrictive. I was referring to any required religion courses in public school, including state and local level.

Some schools have voluntary courses like "Bible as literature". I believe some states teach world religions as part of a history or social studies course - that may be required. I remember learning about the basic tenets of Islam in world history class in 9th grade.

I also know that it makes sense for religious schools, which is why I wrote "public schools".

In most German states (which also has a federal system), public schools do make "religious studies a core subject on par with science, ...." The point of my original reply was that I felt that this was not needed.

I'm glad that we have concluded that we both agree, even if it took quite some time.

Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by emodendroket on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:02PM (#15717513)
I don't know why you have to be so condescending. You don't have to keep replying if you don't think the conversation is productive.
Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by eesmith on Thursday November 16, 2017 @06:43PM (#15717735)
??? I keep thinking you don't understand what I'm saying, and hoping that with a bit more explanation it becomes clear.

I do find it annoying that you seem to be constructing counter-arguments to statements I never made, and indeed thought I specifically avoided.

It looks like we are both on the same page (regarding the importance for mandatory religious education classes in the US), while at the beginning it seems like you were opposed to my original comment.

I thought this conversation was at an end.

Re:Myths About Choosing a College Major by emodendroket on Thursday November 16, 2017 @07:05PM (#15717865)
Alright, then let it be so.