Re:The Fight to Mine Your Data and Sell It to Your Boss
by DannyBee on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:51PM
(#15707624)
It's interesting to see EPIC and EFF on different sides of the same issue. I don't feel like i've ever seen that happen.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Fight to Mine Your Data and Sell It to Your Boss
by Analemma_ on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:16PM
(#15707893)
I wonder if it might've been best for the EFF to just stay out of this one entirely, because it seems like sticking up for either side is defending and normalizing a shitty proposition. I see their point that LinkedIn is abusing the CFAA to stop competitive scrapers, but on the other hand, evil as LinkedIn may be, at least the users on it agreed to its terms. If I sign up for LinkedIn and give them my data, I agreed to that. If HiQ slurps it up, I'm not consenting to whatever sinister things they decide to do with it. That feels wrong and not something the EFF should be sticking up for.
(Disclosure: I used to work for Microsoft, which now owns LinkedIn, although I like to think I'd have this opinion either way)
Re:The Fight to Mine Your Data and Sell It to Your Boss
by 21 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:32PM
(#15708545)
Yes, I don't quite get EFF's point.
So they are saying that anybody should be allowed to scrape anything found online, and use that data for any purpose?
In this case it can be argued they use the data against the physical's person about who the data is.
So they wouldn't object if banks or credit companies would use the data to reject non-desirable people.
Re:The Fight to Mine Your Data and Sell It to Your Boss
by mjevans on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:18PM
(#15708956)
My armchair impression is that the EFF doesn't like the prescient this might set. I think you are correct in them wanting individuals to be able to scrape or otherwise mechanically process anything which they can normally view.
The real chilling effect is from the lack of actual privacy on the data it's self; and the existing asymmetry of power in the employee / employee model as we know it today.
Re:The Fight to Mine Your Data and Sell It to Your Boss
by speedplane on Thursday November 16, 2017 @05:18AM
(#15711531)
Generally, the EFF fights for freedoms to use digital technology. Preventing bots inhibits that freedom, so it does make sense.