No, not everyone is like me and ignores LinkedIn while actively and happily employed, but I imagine enough people are and that it’s not so hard to build models of other user types that work as advertised (as long as they have access to the public data).
HiQ is a threat to LinkedIn on two fronts: as a direct competitor and as a reason for some people to opt out of using the service (though it appears LinkedIn offers similar services, so perhaps the threat is more the Streisand effect at work). That doesn’t mean HiQ should be locked out of the data of course, but it makes for an interesting and complicated situation.
For a big market with small bets (ads) this makes sense. For a small market with big bets (employment) it doesn’t make sense, to me at least.
It doesn't matter if it's not always right, it only matters if it's better than what they have at the moment (ie: almost nothing).
Like the quoted bank said in the article, improving retention by 1% can lower costs by 100 mil per year. Offering a raise to people polishing their Linked in page sounds like low hanging fruit to me.
And of course, employees will try to game the system, which will become smarter and so on.
As I said, there are markets, large markets like ad auctions, where this approach makes sense. But for HR, I'd have to see this being a demonstrable success story before I'd touch it. I think there are better and easier approaches to retention like treating your employees well rather than looking at a statistics dashboard and following its sage if soul-less advice.
Remember, we live in a world where coffee shops and Jimmy Johns (sandwich shop) decided that they needed to subject their employees to pretty draconian non-compete agreements.
However, whether this all is actionable and accurate is another and unfortunately later question. The promoters and customers of that approach might want to read this chapter in the CIA's Psychology of Intelligence Analysis:
Chapter 5: Do You Really Need More Information?
https://www.cia.gov/library/center-for-the-study-of-intellig...
But then they might not have a product to sell or buy.