News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by rnhmjoj on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:03PM (#15707247)
I don't want to start the usual bitcoin scaling debate, but aren't the fees extremely high now?

Using [1] an average transaction costs about 10$, this is particularly bad in a poor country. I wonder if using a cryptocurrency is really the best option in this case.

[1]: https://bitcoinfees.earn.com/

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by narrator on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:36PM (#15708055)
People in these countries don't use Bitcoin for daily purposes. The poor don't use Bitcoin. The middle upper class business owners who can't get access to large amounts of U.S dollars use Bitcoin.

They can have offshore bank accounts but getting the physical cash into and out of the country is tied up in mountains of bureaucracy and corruption. I met a guy in Panama who had to spend half his money getting the other half out of Venezuela. With Bitcoin it is actually possible to save and transfer Bitcoin to cash as needed. Carrying suitcases of hundred dollar bills around is not practical and getting cash in and out of a country like that is almost impossible.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by johnvonneumann on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:33PM (#15707479)
Average transaction cost has been shown to be a bad metric, context:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/7b7jj1/john_newber...

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by colemannugent on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:52PM (#15707625)
This is a very good explanation of the scaling issues Bitcoin is having and how many could be solved if people understood more about how Bitcoin actually works (and SegWit for that matter).
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by Kiro on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:22PM (#15707943)
24 hours? I want it to confirm in 1 second for even less fee than that. How else can Bitcoin become a serious mean of payment?
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by ryanlol on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:21PM (#15708424)
How else can wire transfers become a serious means of payment??
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by Kiro on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:48PM (#15708700)
Do you pay online with wire transfer? My vision is a decentralised coin that is as fast as VISA is perceived but a lot cheaper to transact. Obviously that's not the vision of Bitcoin though?
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by johnvonneumann on Thursday November 16, 2017 @01:34PM (#15715224)
Please don't start on the "Vision" rhetoric, look at the pipeline of core, there is a clear path to VISA scale tx but it is an engineering challenge, unfortunately the majority of people complaining and talking about scaling blocksize (right now, with a terrible straight-up hard-fork) are (bad) Operations people who are more than happy to shitcan half the benefits of a decentralised, privacy focused system for a frankenstein system that in reality still won't compete with VISA. Protip, if you're competing against a behemoth incumbent, it's not enough to simply match their capabilities, you have to surpass them. Lightning network fees will be cheaper than VISA, a lot cheaper. Scaling a $120b financial network on a whim without a real engineering team is not only a bad idea, it's downright fucking deplorable to put users at risk.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by Kiro on Thursday November 16, 2017 @02:25PM (#15715683)
I've never said that Bitcoin Cash is any better. It may have lower fees right now but it still takes ages to transact. I just doubt that any Bitcoin based coin will ever match my vision and that we need something fundamentally different. Maybe Lightning Networks will solve it but it doesn't seem clear.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by ryanlol on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:06PM (#15708879)
I pay salaries with bitcoin, compared to wire transfers it is just amazing.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by gowld on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:11PM (#15707319)
Wow, so that's maybe OK for moving in/out of a >$1000 position, but horrid for spending as a currency.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by PKop on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:09PM (#15707818)
That's why you don't spend it. You save it.

See Their's Law, good money drives out bad.[0] People will hodl Bitcoin and spend fiat, driving up the price of BTC in terms of fiat until it absorbs some significant portion of global currency value. There are only 21 M coins; a deflationary crypto currency isn't for buying coffee or micro-payments.

It is displaying similar qualities to Gold in countries where governments have debased the currency.

[0] http://nakamotoinstitute.org/mempool/speculative-attack/

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by gowld on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:47PM (#15708687)
How can this be? BTC is deflating far faster than USD is inflating, considering USD purchasing power. So BTC can't be picking up USD's weakness, it must be a speculative bubble.

Were Beanie Babies good money driving out bad? https://qz.com/114753/meet-the-family-who-lost-100000-when-t...

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by PKop on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @07:32PM (#15709330)
Because it's not at a steady state yet. At what price did you expect it to reach some semblance of stability? 0.10.. $10, $100... ?

Well, there are some broad metrics we can think about. If Bitcoin become a sort of reserve currency, or a digital gold, or a combination of both, shouldn't its total market value be a proportion of what currently occupies that title?

So, do the math. X% of Gold, or X% of reserve currency. Inject that value into 21 million Bitcoin (or the circulating supply at a given moment).

Here's a valuation prediction applying Bitcoin daily trade volume of 10% of foreign exchanges which are $5 Trillion[0]. This would price BTC at $100,000.

Only after it approaches somewhere close to these numbers, would you expect to see appreciation in the range of fiat inflation.

That's how it can be.

[0] https://www.cnbc.com/2017/05/31/bitcoin-price-forecast-hit-1...

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by aqsheehy on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:02PM (#15708843)
Bitcoin is for the dark net markets; for everything else, there's MasterCard
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by paulmd on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:01PM (#15707729)
There is little reason to prefer Bitcoin to US Dollars or Euros for those looking to avoid the effects of inflation. There is nothing uniquely difficult about getting hard currencies on the black market in such places, it's simply that most people cannot afford it - and will not be able to afford Bitcoin either. It's a dumb suggestion from breathless fanboys who didn't really think about the actual problem before pushing their solution.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by freeloop3 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:08PM (#15707814)
You can't confiscate a brain wallet
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by paulmd on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:37PM (#15708064)
This $5 wrench says otherwise.

https://xkcd.com/538/

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by freeloop3 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:47PM (#15708688)
Torture only works if you are sure of the existence of such a thing. It's easy to order the police to go from home to home, confiscating valuables. It's a lot harder to know if someone has bitcoin, and if so how much they have. Even if you can get them to admit they have it, and give you access to n wallets, they may always have n+1
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by paulmd on Thursday November 16, 2017 @12:50PM (#15714766)
> Torture only works if you are sure of the existence of such a thing.

I don't think you comprehend the workings of "mass terror". Here's how it goes: we'll make you watch while we beat up your wife and kids until you tell us something worth knowing.

No evidence necessary. Pretty much everybody has some valuables, or knows someone who does, and if not who cares? It's your funeral.

Once again, the nerdy preconception that thugs somehow operate on a legalistic or technical basis is just completely wrong. You'll be the one "giving" the valuables to them, to make it stop.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by zaarn on Thursday November 16, 2017 @03:10AM (#15710940)
You don' need evidence, just hit them with a wrench until bitcoins come out or they stop moving.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by gatmne on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @06:23PM (#15708994)
doesn't scale to all citizens of Zimbabwe :)
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by paulmd on Thursday November 16, 2017 @12:54PM (#15714797)
Surely when these hypothetical thugs are going around beating people up and confiscating their paper money, they can spare a few moments to beat people up and take their Bitcoin while they're at it?
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by nikcub on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:07PM (#15707284)
The 137,000 satoshi price quoted isn't an average - it's the price to have your transaction almost guaranteed to be accepted in the next block

It also shows 30 satoshi a byte gets you transaction accepted in 3-80 blocks, which based on experience is usually 3-12 blocks - and that works out to be 50c for the average transaction

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by drdaeman on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:03PM (#15707753)
I believe, dust collection is prohibitively costly. And if one's using Bitcoin any actively, they'll end up generating a lot of dust, I think.

At the current BTC/USD rates, I have a few dollars worth of dust. However, it's spread over 17 inputs, so it's basically unspendable. It would require ~3.1KB transaction so even at 30sat/byte the fees would be, like, 0.00093 BTC ($6.5 at $7K/BTC).

For poorer countries even $2-5 could be a well significant amount. One can probably have a meal for that money.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by freeloop3 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:12PM (#15707860)
> For poorer countries even $2-5 could be a well significant amount. One can probably have a meal for that money.

Or ten... You're a little out of touch for whom you speak for.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by drdaeman on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:15PM (#15707884)
Yes. You're right.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by nikcub on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:14PM (#15708361)
Many wallets and users don't do dust sweeps anymore since it associates all the utxo's with a single user and reduces your privacy

Theres nothing wrong with having many utxo's of varying sizes - good wallets will give you a choice on how to select them when composing a transaction (such as Electrum) and you can sweep part of it back to yourself in what would otherwise look like any other transaction

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by bduerst on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:31PM (#15707456)
For POS transactions though don't you want it to be instant?

3-12 blocks is half a hour to two hours wait. The chart shows 30 satoshis/byte to take 40 minutes to a 19 hours total wait.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by thephyber on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:47PM (#15707596)
I think it's important to consider the alternative.

In Zimbabwe, you could lose a significant percentage of your cash's value if you delay a purchase. Taking a risk that the other side of the transaction might not be as big of a problem if you can look at their account balance before the transaction begins.

Sure, you risk getting caught in a double-spend that is rejected from the blockchain, but if the alternative is to hold onto cash or to lose out on a transaction in a tough economy, you might be willing to take on that risk.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by gruez on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:36PM (#15707496)
i think that's strawman at this point. even if bitcoin had 1GB block sizes, bringing the wait time to 1 block (10 minutes), it's still not going to be acceptable for POS. it's either going to be on-chain with no confirmations, or through layer2 protocols.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by xorcist on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:08PM (#15708313)
Orphan blocks are common, one block has never been considered secure. Early in Bitcoin, a best practice emerged to consider six blocks secure. So that takes an hour, best case.

(Given the insane hash power now maybe that standard can be lowered, but on the other hand it's not common to get a spot in the next block anymore.)

So point of sale was never a good fit for Bitcoin. What most real world merchants do when the amount is small enough is to eat the risk. Even if it's easy to double spend in practice most customers won't bother for a can of coke.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by nikcub on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @03:57PM (#15707684)
Accepting zero confirmation transactions at POS is a different problem to fees (which are atm admitantly high but that should improve)

Merchant picks a solution based on who they integrate with - something like BitGo Instant[0], GreenAddress[1] or an analytics/fraud API provider that adds a risk score to a tx no different to a credit card transaction

[0] https://www.bitgo.com/solutions#instant

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by SilasX on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:00PM (#15707719)
You definitely do want it to be instant, but this isn't quite an apples-to-apples comparison.

That two-hour figure is the amount to get the transaction to the point of irreversibility so it can be re-spent without worry. The equivalent figure for credit cards is ~45 days and checks can take a week to clear.

But you're right, making transactions on chain is not going to be practical in an untrusted environment and it still depends on intermediaries.

Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by uncoder0 on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @04:33PM (#15708035)
What you're describing sounds like zero confirmation transactions which bitcoin used to support before RBF. You can't reliably take zero-conf in btc anymore though. So you have to wait for settlement to turn over goods or services.
Re:Bitcoin surges in Zimbabwe after military seize power by xorcist on Wednesday November 15, 2017 @05:15PM (#15708369)
Zero conf was never secure. Many did demonstrate double spends long before RBF was thought of.

Still, that argument was made against RBF and was enough of a hindrade to consensus that RBF was made opt-in. And it still is. So you are absolutely free to accept zero conf transactions, and take the risk, as long as you don't accept those who flag for RBF. Most wallets won't even make them by default (which in my opinion is stupid with the fees we have today).

The argument for a golden age before RBF isn't a good one. It was never reliable. And what little reliability it had is unchanged.