Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by cm2187 on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @04:26AM
(#15693750)
But the potential price is more suicide attacks in the streets of Paris or London. Not a concern of the SDF of course (and who could blame them?), but what outcome is more desirable from a western point of view is less obvious to me.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by brazzy on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @06:25AM
(#15694160)
You really think murdering women and children will lead to less suicide attacks in the future?
That kind of short-sighted inhumane idiocy is exactly what keeps fueling the whole mess!
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by emn13 on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @07:19AM
(#15694400)
Come on, that's a strawman - you know that. It's not like there was a briefing with two options: mass murder, or let the bad guys retreat: pick one. Nor are the causes of "the whole mess" that trivially pinpointable.
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by boomboomsubban on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @06:39AM
(#15694222)
Continued fighting would have killed thousands of more civilians, while France and Great Britain have had under a thousand terrorism related deaths since 1970. How isn't this obvious?
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by Zpalmtree on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @07:53AM
(#15694561)
Because we value our own citizens higher than the lives of terrorists?
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by bjl on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @08:08AM
(#15694629)
The vast majority of people killed in Syria were not terrorists.
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by boomboomsubban on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @09:35AM
(#15695297)
Civilians aren't terrorists, though your own citizens might be.
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by belorn on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @06:41AM
(#15694234)
There will always be a potential price to pay as long a single person lives that we define as enemy or define us as enemy. This is the classical reason why nations create final solutions to a conflict. Its a choice between a bad outcome and a really bad outcome, and I doubt neither is currently desired by a western point of view.
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by raverbashing on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @05:00AM
(#15693862)
Then maybe the west should actually check who crosses their borders instead of just waving anyone through if they come from a boat
And increase their intelligence resources and not be afraid to act on radical preachers
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by icebraining on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @05:22AM
(#15693932)
What makes you think the West doesn't check who crosses the borders? What do you think the dozens of thousands of people stuck in detaining centers all over Greece and Italy are waiting for?
Re:A deal that let hundreds of IS fighters and their familie...
by emn13 on Tuesday November 14, 2017 @07:14AM
(#15694379)
You do realize that e.g. the US spends approximately as much on the DHS (which is primarily borders+immigration stuff) as on the FBI, CIA, NSA, DEA and FBP (federal prisons) combined? And that's the US, which through history and geography has had the luck of relatively trivial borders?
Border control is a huge focus! It's also an almost impossible task, which is not something people want to hear.
It'd be easier to claim western countries spend too much on controlling their borders simply because all that cash doesn't seem to have had the desired effect, judging by popular opinion.